Wall Street Outsiders Versus Hedge Funds
By Dr. Mark W. Hendrickson
The investment world was convulsed last week when at least one hedge fund (Melvin Capital) lost billions of dollars. The sudden, massive losses happened when a tidal wave of independent individual investors, spearheaded by posts on reddit.com, triggered a short squeeze that torpedoed the hedge fund.
For those of you unfamiliar with a “short squeeze,” let me explain. Most stock market investors “go long.” That means that they buy a stock and then hope to sell it later at a higher price. Short sellers do the same thing except in reverse sequence—that is, they sell first, hopefully at a high price—and then buy later, hopefully at a lower price. Whereas “long” investors make money when the price rises, short sellers make money when it falls.
A short squeeze happens when increased buying volume starts to push the price higher. Every dollar the price rises inflicts losses on short-sellers. Because the only way to sell a stock short (that is, to sell a stock you don’t have) is to borrow it from a broker, the short seller not only pays interest on the borrowed shares, but as the price rises, the short seller is legally required to transfer more money in his brokerage account to make sure that the lender doesn’t end up eating the losses. These are the infamous “margin calls.” The more the stock rises, the larger the margin calls; thus, the more the short-sellers are “squeezed.” The only way to stop losing money is to exit the short position by buying back the stock. But guess what? Buying back the stock adds to the buying pressure, pushing the price of the stock up even more, causing more short-sellers to capitulate and buy back their shares. It’s a vicious cycle that can lead to a buying frenzy.
That is exactly what happened last week. The stock of a company called GameStop Corp., which had been trading under $20 per share for ages, rose to over $400 per share in just a couple of days when an unorganized gang of individual investors—the “reddit mob”—bought lots of GameStop’s shares. This triggered a massive short squeeze that caught Melvin Capital off guard. Melvin’s strategists apparently had no exit plan in the case of the market turning against them, so they got roasted by the short squeeze, suffering massive losses.
One interesting aspect of this debacle is that the number of shares of GameStop that had been sold short reportedly exceeded the total number of shares in existence. That means that some sellers were short the same shares at the same time. I’m not sure if that is even legal, but surely federal regulators need to look into that anomaly.
The individuals who bought GameStop made huge amounts of money—the money that the hedge funds lost—from the short squeeze that they had caused. We shouldn’t feel sorry for the hedge funds. They only allow high-net worth individuals to invest with them, because they know that the investment techniques they use—leverage, derivatives, short sales, etc.—are very risky. Thus, when a massive loss actually materializes, there is nothing unfair about it. It was simply the consequence of the risks they deliberately took.
However, instead of letting the short squeeze take its natural course and eventually come to an exhaustion point, at which the stock price would likely collapse, thereby inflicting huge losses on those still holding the shares (the “longs”), the so-called “powers that be” in the financial world intervened and tried to check Melvin’s losses. We probably don’t know yet who all these “powers” are, but we do know that they included brokerage firms that arbitrarily limited the number of shares of GameStop and certain other securities that individual investors were permitted to buy. This was designed to halt the short squeeze, and so prevent individual investors from making more money at hedge funds’ expense—essentially changing the rules of the game in midstream, rigging the market in favor of the wealthy Wall Street insiders.
Think about it: When small investors lose their shirts by placing unwise investments, do brokerage firms, hedge funds, big banks, etc., come to their rescue? Not a chance. Yet when the big boys were losing their shirts, their Wall Street pals rushed to their aid. In a battle between man-on-the-street Davids and Wall Street Goliaths (hedge funds), the establishment clearly favored Goliath. This episode is reminiscent of the “too big to fail” syndrome that was so prominent in the Wall Street bailouts back in 2008. No wonder people despise Wall Street. Who can blame them?
Dr. Mark W. Hendrickson is a retired adjunct faculty member, economist, and fellow for economic and social policy with the Institute for Faith and Freedom at Grove City College.
More Resources
Unable to open RSS Feed $XMLfilename with error HTTP ERROR: 404, exitingMore Investing Information:
Related Articles
How Can You Learn About Today's Market Trends?
Stock market trading is the exchange of trade certificates that vouch for the partial ownership of a particular company for a set price. Through stock trading, companies are able to raise funds that they use for various operational aspects.
Stock Scalping 101
Stock scalping refers to the illegal and deceptive practice of recommending that others purchase a security while secretly selling the same security. In recent years, the SEC and Justice Department have brought an increasing number of cases involving securities violations that involve scalping activity.
Rule 144 & the Adequate Current Public Information Standard
Rule 144(c) of the Securities Act of 1933, as amended (the "Securities Act") requires that stockholders of public companies relying upon the Rule to satisfy the adequate current public information requirement. The requirements depend upon whether the issuer is a reporting or non-reporting company.
How To Profit Using Technical Indicators
You can learn to profit from options using a few key techinical indicators. These simple tools will enable you to profit from options in any market condition.
Future Assist - Self Managed Superannuation set up and Investing
Future Assist are self managed superannutaion set up and investing specialists. Located in Sydney, Brisbane, Gold Coast and Melbourne.
Electronic Currency Exchange
One of the easiest ways to make money online today is to learn e-currency trading. Many people have spent countless hours looking for the perfect program that will make them a millionaire over night. The truth is, these programs do not exist. Electronic currency exchange allows people to make a long-term investment that can yield substantial profits in years to come.
Income Investing: Selecting the Right Stuff
You don't have to be a professional Investment Manager to professionally manage your investment portfolio, but you do need to have a long term plan and know something about Asset Allocation... a portfolio organization tool that is often misunderstood and almost always improperly used within the financial community. Remember, your unhappiness is Wall Street's most coveted asset. Don't humor them.
Investment Advisors 101 - Ask Some Questions
Why do people become Investment Advisors? Call me skeptical, but I don't think it's the ethereal glow they feel after implementing your new Financial Plan. Actually (once you appreciate that IAs are the primary delivery system for Wall Street's huge collection of one-size-fits-all products), you'll realize that it's the money.
New Retirement Savings Plan - Roth 401(k) Coming Into Effect
Unlike a traditional 401(k) Retirement Plan, a Roth 401k plan applies to all employees but the latter requires the contributions to the plan account with after-tax dollars while a 401k plan allows for contributions with pre-tax dollars.
The 40 Year Plan Over
What is truly driving the market of self directed IRA retirement investing? Is it the buff real estate market? Or are there other economic factors?
10 Essential Trading Elements
While most beginning traders focus their study on when to enter a position, traders who make money know that the money goes to those who do a lot of other things right. Here are ten things that every trader must know:
How to Begin Trading Commodities Futures
This instructional guide should help you in your first steps when it comes to futures trading. It might not give you all the answers, but it contains the most important elements that should help before you trade in these instruments.
Secure Your Retirement with a Rollover IRA
Switching your job? Retiring? Congratulations! A window of opportunity opens for you with the Rollover Individual Retirement Account or Rollover IRA.
Annuity Quotes
Choose an annuity quote that comes from the right source. Ensure that your agent is licensed, knowledgeable, reputable and experienced. It is always best to go for an agent that comes as a recommended source.
Purpose of NTL
NTL clarifies the method of Gulf of Mexico OCS Region (GOMR) regarding the implementation of requirements for general lease surety bonds that are present in 30 CFR 256, Subpart I.