New Drug Pricing Executive Order Burdens Patients


By Kenneth E. Thorpe

President Trump just signed an executive order designed to reduce drug prices. Dubbed a "Most Favored Nations" policy, the order pegs Medicare payments for medicines to the prices paid by foreign governments.

This plan would reduce access to today's innovative medicines and stifle medical progress. It must be shelved. There are much better ideas for reducing prescription drug costs.

Many foreign nations have single-payer health systems that impose strict price controls on new medicines and refuse to cover particularly expensive drugs.

Patients living in those nations end up with fewer treatment options. Patients in the United Kingdom and France had access to just seven in 10 new cancer therapies between 2011 and 2018. American patients could access to virtually all of them.

The U.S. market operates differently. Insurers compete for patients -- often by offering generous drug coverage. Drug researchers are incentivized to develop new treatments, as they know that American patients value innovation. As a result, research companies across the world generally launch their newest drugs here first.

The executive order will slow medical progress. There are currently 4,500 drugs in America's development pipeline. These medicines target everything from cancer and HIV to heart disease and asthma. Price controls would inevitably reduce drug firms' revenues -- and leave them less to invest in research and development. This could block the next generation of drugs from ever even hitting the pharmacy shelf.

Medical breakthroughs are constantly making it easier and cheaper for patients to stay healthy. A recent study from my organization, the Partnership to Fight Chronic Disease, found that new medicines could avoid $6 trillion in healthcare costs and prevent 16 million deaths by 2030.

It isn't fair that Americans pay so much more than Canadians and Europeans. But policymakers should work to get these nations to shoulder more of the research burden - not import their harmful policies.

Kenneth E. Thorpe is a professor of health policy at Emory University and chairman of the Partnership to Fight Chronic Disease. This piece originally ran in the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette.

More Resources


06/17/2024
What Biden and Trump Must Say To Win the Debate
In just under two weeks, President Joe Biden and Republican challenger former President Donald Trump will square off in the first of two televised debates, with immense implications for the 2024 presidential election.

more info


06/17/2024
The Moment Everyone Realized Biden's Not Fit for Office
When the last Democrat to occupy the White House has to literally grab the current one because he notices he's had yet another senior moment and appears to be paralyzed on stage, it h...

more info


06/17/2024
Dems Are Split Over Biden's Asylum Order
Some feel limiting US-Mexico border crossings will protect the country, while others say 'it violates American values'

more info


06/17/2024
Biden's Border Order Is Kabuki
Don't be fooled; stronger action is available without more laws.

more info


06/17/2024
GOP Looks to Trump To Turn Up Heat on Tester and Brown
Former President Trump is turning up the heat on Sens. Jon Tester (D-Mont.) and Sherrod Brown (D-Ohio) as Senate Republicans stand on the precipice of winning back the majority.

more info


06/17/2024
Historic Numbers of Black Voters Under 50 Giving Up on Dems
CNN's Harry Enten takes a look at polls showing black voters under 50 defecting from the Democratic Party.

more info


06/17/2024
How John Roberts Lost His Court
A self-described documentary filmmaker, trolling a gala dinner for a gotcha moment by engaging Supreme Court justices in conversation and

more info


06/17/2024
Bar Group to Members: Don't Call Trump Verdict 'Partisan'
The Connecticut Bar Association is encouraging its members to speak out against public officials' criticism of the judicial system after former President Trump's recent convictions - and to perhaps think twice before offering their own opinions.

more info


06/17/2024
SCOTUS Controversy About More Than 'Appeal to Heaven'


more info


06/17/2024
A Great Nothingburger: Rolling Stone's Hilarious Alito 'Scoop'


more info


06/17/2024
We Invited Butker To Speak. We Won't Bow To Cancel Culture
The demand that we weigh in on Harrison Butker's speech is exactly the kind of problem Benedictine College hopes to counteract in American culture.

more info


06/17/2024
The Resistance To a New Trump Admin Has Already Started
An emerging coalition that views Donald J. Trump's agenda as a threat to democracy is laying the groundwork to push back if he wins in November, taking extraordinary pre-emptive actions.

more info


06/17/2024
How Left-Wing Conspiracies Work
When we hear such things in the months to come, remember that these mythologies are usually a warning: what the left is alleging is, quite often, precisely what the left is already doing.

more info


06/17/2024
Republican Rats Return to Trump's Ship
Trump's visit to the US Capitol - where the Republicans he almost got killed three years ago fawned over him - would be funny if it weren't pathetic

more info


06/17/2024
Don't Fall for Biden's Nice Old Man Act
Biden might act like a doddering incompetent, look like a wax effigy and walk like a robot, but the president has the uncanny ability to exceed all expectations when it counts, politically.

more info



Custom Search

More Politics Articles:

Related Articles

Trump's Prescription Drug Pricing Reform Will Have Unintended Consequences


President Trump just signed an executive order that aims to tackle U.S. prescription drug spending.. The order pegs the prices of certain drugs covered by Medicare to the lower prices paid in other developed countries, whose governments impose strict price controls.

Seizing Patents Will Hamper COVID-19 Vaccine Development


It's full speed ahead on the scientific front in the fight against COVID-19. We're on track to have an arsenal of vaccines and medicines for the novel coronavirus within a year.

Fix Our Medical Insurance Dilemma


Give all Americans the option to buy into Medicare. I've paid into Social Security and Medicare my entire life. I'm still paying to be on plan B and supplemental coverage. I also pay for prescription insurance. I often feel like a coffee coupon from McDonald's would pay for about as much medicine as my prescription card pays.

Pandemic Hasn't Broken the Employer Health Insurance System


Over 55 million Americans have filed for unemployment since COVID-19 struck. But for the most part, they haven't lost their health insurance. An astounding 98 percent of workers who had employer-sponsored health benefits before the pandemic are still enrolled in workplace plans, according to a July report.

With New Drug Pricing Order, Trump Flirts with Socialism


President Trump's recent executive order on drug prices gets almost everything right -- except the solution.

Executive Order for Price Controls Will Harm Innovation and Patients


President Trump just signed a new executive order to reform our healthcare system. While his desire to lower costs for patients is appropriate, the proposed changes would do more harm than good.

Where Has the Truth Gone?


“Want to buy a new car with bad credit? No problem. Come into our dealership and we will get you approved—guaranteed! You will be pre-approved in two minutes—100 percent are accepted. You will not be denied, no matter your circumstances. Don’t get unnecessarily hassled by other dealers, you deserve a new ride.”

Martin Luther King, Jr. and America’s "Promissory Note"


Each January, we honor Martin Luther King, Jr. for his leadership in combating racial segregation and securing civil rights for African Americans. However, critics lately have charged that King’s legacy has been “whitewashed,” or remembered selectively. A 2019 Guardian editorial laments that Americans have “Disneyfied” the reformer, saying that we recall his earlier, comforting successes while overlooking his later frustrations and political radicalism. Psychologizing the critique, a 2020 NBC News opinion piece decries that King’s memory is abused for the purpose of cultivating “complacency” and a sense of “absolution.”

Minimum Wage, Maximum Discrimination


Since the days of Adam Smith, economists have sought a set of social institutions which permit “neither dominion, nor discrimination,” to use Nobel Prize-winning economist James Buchanan’s phrase. In this, economists are joined by all people of goodwill—including those in the Biden administration, which has enshrined equity and inclusion as cornerstones of how they’ll govern.

Don't Put Community Cancer Care Centers Out of Business


Ruth is a 67-year-old woman living with metastatic lung cancer. She receives care at a treatment center near her home in rural southern Illinois. There are larger hospitals over an hour away in St. Louis, but she doesn't have the time or financial resources to travel there as often as she would need to.

From the Dawn of the American Twilight


Fifty years ago this spring, my wife and I, both Air Force intelligence officers, returned to Udorn Air Base, Thailand from an “in-country rest & recuperation” trip to Chaing Mai. That night I worked the mid-shift in the intel shop at headquarters 7/13th Air Force. It fell to me to prepare and deliver the morning intelligence briefing to the major general who thought he ran air operations in Northern Laos; a delusion since that war was run by the U.S. Department of State and the CIA with Air Force support.

Outside the Lines: American Corporations and Society


During a heated 1990 U.S. Senate race in North Carolina between the Republican incumbent Jesse Helms and Democratic challenger Harvey Gantt, basketball superstar and North Carolina native Michael Jordan was asked to endorse Gantt’s candidacy.

God, Joe Biden, and the National Day of Prayer


President Joe Biden’s omission of the word God from his National Day of Prayer proclamation last week has evoked a firestorm of protest. Christian Broadcasting Network commentator David Brody, evangelist Franklin Graham, Catholic League president Bill Donohue, Fox News, and other politically conservative media outlets all criticized Biden’s failure to mention God.

Government-Funded Labs Don't Invent New Drugs


House Democrats just introduced a bill designed to lower prescription drug prices. It doesn't. But wait, it gets worse. The Lower Drug Costs Now Act, or H.R. 3, is a reprise of a 2019 bill that passed the House but failed to gain support in the Senate.

Pandemic Proves Value of Homecare


Doctors, nurses, and the scientists who created COVID-19 vaccines have all emerged as heroes during the pandemic. But there's another, underappreciated group that's been crucial to the country's pandemic response -- those who provide home-based medical equipment, services, and care.