Airlines, Price Wars, and Branding

Here are some thoughts on the study of the theory of price wars as they relate to the industries like the Airlines and others. Comments on an article in Harvard Business Review in March-April edition 2000. The article was called 'How to Win a PRICE WAR'. Written by Akshay R. Rao, Mark E. Bergen and Scott Davis.

They start out the article, that in the game of business, many tactics are used to ward off competitors. Increasingly PRICE is the weapon of choice. It talks about how the quest for market share and market dominance by continually lowering prices by each side of a price war can drive down Industry Profits. Oh Really? But who cares what the Industry does anyway. Is it not the consumer that pays for your dinner and youremployee's kids college tuition? It sites the 1992 Airline wars Between American, Northwest and others as an example. The result was record air travel and record losses. Surely this example cannot be used in modern context, because at the time each airline was flying both McDonald Douglas, Boeing and Lockheed Aircraft. With Pratt Whitney and/or GE Engines. Similar in fuel consumptions, similar ticket distribution system, similar airport landing fees and similar customer base.

Now to really win that war and decrease losses you would have to become more efficient in reservations, cut staff, more efficient in facilities, feeder airlines, scheduling, fuel consumption and in other services related to airline travel you were involved with. They did not, they simply engaged in a price war, to shake out the weak. Now for the consumer the lower prices were great, for the stockholder they were not. But they could have been. The authors site this as damaging the industry. An Industry that takes wartime aviation advances and a few years after to allow for the new technology to reach the private sector with new and efficient aerodynamics and electronic positioning and fuel allocation devices.

If the MBA number crunchers would look at the real problems and design a superior system in the airlines at that time rather than always doing the obvious and previous chess moves then they might get an upper hand. Because necessity is the mother of invention. Price can drive the market and the winner in the most free of Friedman models would be that company which can innovate and adapt and US MARINE their way to the next level, like is such in the new digital economy. But airplanes only go so fast, there is friction, drag, lift, weight and thrust and that is all you can get right? Wrong. Remember when Chuck Yeager broke the Speed of Sound in the Bell X-1? It was impossible. And the Moon? Never! You see it is those who do not or will not push the envelope and not dare to risk that will lose in the price war. The Industry? Who cares about the Industry. Re-create it. An Industry is a boundary, so is the atmosphere, the copper cable lines, the ones and zeros that make up computer language. Industries set standards. Break them. Industry set limits, ignore them, Industries make experts. Challenge them. Industries print magazines and give advice, do not read it. Driving down prices in any Industry makes that Industry and forces the weak to either adapt or exit the market place.

Their article is like saying that an Olympic athlete who works out too hard and sacrifices too much should slow down to 5-minute miles in the Marathon and let the other runners catch up. Hog wash. Or let the other basketball team score more points and put in your weakest players so that it makes the game look close? Why, Capitalistic markets dictate competition and competition dictates compelling reason to excel. I say take that challenge, deliver great quality, lower prices and raised standards. Oh Sure the Unions want everyone to get paid for as little work as possible, too, they do not want a wage war either. But a wage war might improve efficiency. Less work for may pay. Who does that help? Is that not a little short sided? All that does is reward inefficiency. We are to believe by this article that a price war hurts an Industry? Who says the Industry should be allowed to exist? The consumer or the Industry?

Is Harvard Business School so hard up for articles that it will allow this type of content and flawed thinking into their reviews? Why should you reward an Industry and recommend against price wars? Should we then have price collusion and price fixing? That is the other option. A price war weakens Industries? Or does it keep them in check, and keep them from getting too fat, dumb and happy? Strong survive, free market economies are theoretically based on the evolution of business. Just because an Industry forms Associations and lobbyists and sets standards of price and quality, does not mean it should be allowed to garnish higher prices from consumers and not have market pressures of competition, especially the major market pressure of price, which will always be the great equalizer in the current system all businesses in the US operate under.

One quote in the article is hysterical:

PRICE WARS CAN CREATE ECONOMICALLY DEVASTATING AND PSYCOLOGICALLY DEBILITATING SITUATIONS THAT TAKE AN EXTRAORDINARY TOLL ON AN INDIVIDUAL, A COMPANY, AND INDUSTRY PROFITABILITY.

Lots of big words guys, but this reader does not buy it. First off nobody said life was suppose to be stress free in personal life, business or otherwise. When you are born, during birth your body is under more stress moving through the birth canal than at any other time in your life. So forget about this easy ride thing. The strong survive. No athlete can expect to stay on top without hours of training, commitment, sacrifice and training. Nor should they be allowed to. Because world records are not won without competition and pushing of the envelope. Likewise no business should be allowed to operate at anything less than optimum efficiency. If they do they are lazy and they should be challenged, this helps the dynamics associated with a free economy.

The airline example does not take into consideration some of the strides made by some of the then competing airlines. Continental Airlines instituted a fuel savings program to Pilots who were given a percentage of Lbs saved in fuel as a bonus. By cutting off the direct paths from station to station (VOR) they were able to save fuel and time in flight, thus able to lower cruising speeds, less drag on the hyperbolic curve and save millions each day in fuel. This came out of the price wars. Many other similar efficiencies also came out of those price wars.

The authors then site the long distance charges war started by Sprint on weekends at 5 cents per minute and then matched by MCI and AT&T. Good for consumers and now we may see in a few years no long distance charges in Continental US. This hurt Industry profits. Yes, but so what. Consumers got a better deal, and if the phones companies were at the top of their game then they would have been able to offer those savings prior and not been caught off guard by Sprints move. Why did they already not offer these lower prices since they could have?

What these authors and Professors did not mention is that the best way to win a price war is simple. Start the price war, but not until you are 100% at the top of your game. If you are at the top you can win a price war. But be active, not re-active. Be the price breaker, the ball buster, the Iron fist. Move to make the first blow, so deep, so hard, without falter and be ready to move, and adapt with the battle. Take what is yours because you are at the top of the game. Be ready to make unexpected moves at a split second and fire blow after blow. Be ready to break Industry norms, forget the rules, the perception of the Industry, disregard its experts, its leadership, its foundation. If you want to run at redline in a race with cars that go all the same speed and use only part of the track then go ahead. But this team and teams like it in various Industries all over will beat you.

Because the first thing they teach us at racecar driving school is use the whole track. And if you are not in the unlimited class then you are controlled by weight, speed, size and timing. If you let others set your limits then the authors have a point, in all other cases they need to stop writing articles. Publish or Perish? Whatever guys, I guess if you cannot, you can always teach.

I love price wars and we have never entered a market area, digitally or anologely, that we have not won when implementing a price war.

Rule number one when competing for price. START THE WAR.

Number two. BE READY TO ADAPT.

Number three. BE THE BEST AND MOST EFFICIENT BEFORE YOU START.

Number four. DO NOT FOLLOW ANY INDUSTRY STANDARDS OR SET ANY LIMITS.

Number five. DO NOT HAVE A TIME LIMIT ON THE WAR. WAR IS HELL ASSUME IT LAST FOREVER.

Number six. HAVE SUPPLIERS ON YOUR TEAM.

Number seven. TELL THE WHOLE WORLD ABOUT YOUR PRICE CUT AND WHY.

Number eight. RAISE STANDARDS OF QUALITY AND EASE OF USE FOR CUSTOMERS SIMULTANEOUSLY.

Number nine. BUNDLE SERVICES RIGHT BEFORE YOU START THE WAR.

Number ten. RUN THE PRICE WAR IN ALL AREAS AT ONCE.

Number eleven. LOWER PRICES BY ONLY 60% OF WHAT YOU CAN, SAVING FORTY FOR LATER, WHEN THE REAL WAR BEGINS.

Number twelve. HAVE CAPACITY RADY TO TAKE ON NEW CUSTOMER BASES AS COMPETITORS LEAVE THE MARKET.

Number thirteen. CREATE A MASSIVE DIVERSION RIGHT BEFORE YOU START SO THEY WILL NOT SEE IT COMING.

Number fourteen. GET THE INDUSTRY TO AGREE ON PRICES AND CUSTOMER SERVICE ISSUES BEFORE YOU ATTACK.

Number fifteen. MAKE THE INDUSTRY DEFEND THEIR POSITIONS AND TRACK RECORDS.

Number sixteen. HAVE INSIDER INFORMATION ON YOUR COMPETITION AND KNOW THEIR NEXT MOVE.

Number seventeen. ADVISE YOUR COMPETITORS THAT THEY ARE BREAKING THE INDUSTRY NORM, EVERYTIME THEY LOWER SERVIC TO COMPETE ON PRICE, AND ALERT THE INDUSTRY NEWS.

Number eighteen. GO STEATH-SILENT FOR THRE MONTHS PRIOR TO WAR.

Number nineteen. MOVE SWIFTLY, AND ATTACK IN YOUR COMPETITORS MOST PEAK SEASON, RIGHT AFTER THEIR SLOWEST MONTH.

Number twenty. HAVE BRAND NAME RECOGINITION TO CARRY YOU THROUGH.

Number twenty one through twenty five and the most important of all. I CANNOT TELL YOU THESE.

Many business books will tell you, you cannot have price or quality. BS-Have both, who says it has to be one or the other? The Experts, the professors, the Industry Leadership? Who cares what they think. Business Industry Leadership will say at the start of any price war,

YOU GET WHAT YOU PAY FOR! NOBODY CAN AFFORD TO DO IT THAT CHEAP.

Yes but are you paying for what you are getting? That phrase is a simple cop out. And can no one there really not do it? Or are they admitting that they can not do it and are projecting their inferiority onto your company, like personifying an inanimate object. Nobody can keep up that Marathon pace. Good keep thinking that. If you have inside information that this is occurring you are winning and should lower it again, because they will surely never catch up for lost ground or lost market share and you have the synergy and the power of presence on your side. This is how markets are won. A denial, and a sure sign that you have competition, who not only does not understand your Industry, but also cannot allow themselves to adapt. Pray for this scenario to take place, it is typical and means you are doing it right.

Take a company for instance, which has Great prices, great service, great customer base, great image, on the leading edge of all aspects and more efficient than the nearest competitors. A company like Dell. So when they wage a price war on the competitors in our markets, who wins? The consumer number one. And Dell because the competition cannot participate in our price war. Overhead too high, and they refuse to break Industry ranks. All the while the consumers overwhelmingly choose Dell, not Gateway or HP-Compaq. Why. For all the same reasons above.

There are Lots of great examples of case studies in the article, all out of context and few touch on any depth to prove any points, except that the authors are well read. I would challenge any of these authors to put money on any company any company in the PC business industry. PRICE WAR is the weapon of choice, it is the same as picking up the pace in a Marathon. If you are the better runner you leave everyone else in the dust, if you are not the best runner, it is your fault for not preparing or training tough enough in the life you lived for the decades leading up to that event. Be the best and start the war, raise the bar, raise the standards, pick up the pace and lower the prices, then be prepared to finish a marathon.

You know what, the crowd will love you even more than the consumers. Just Ask: AVIS, Ford, Microsoft, Block Buster, E-trade, Amazon.com, JB HUNT, SWIFT, GE, AT&T, Taco Bell, South West Airlines, anyway you get the point.

"Lance Winslow" - If you have innovative thoughts and unique perspectives, come think with Lance; www.WorldThinkTank.net/wttbbs

More Resources

Entering Business Aviation, Part IV: Crafting a Resume
Writing a résumé can be one of the most daunting parts of any job search. Quite frankly, it is one of the most important elements in helping you finding work.
Tips to Finding Really Cheap Airline Tickets
Finding really cheap airline tickets onlineLooking for a really good deal on flights? Here are some of the best strategies used to find really cheap airline tickets online.1) Really Cheap Airline Tickets: Last minute flightsOften you'll find really cheap airline tickets posted at the last minute.
Several Facts to Obtaining Cheap Airfares
AirfaresNeed a vacation but dont want to stay around town? Want to go somewhere exotic, somewhere different? Want to fly but worried about the airfare? Sourcing the cheapest airfare available has been made easier with competition growing between travel agencies as people realize that a vacation need not be all that expensive. Airfare can be a hindrance to the best of vacation plans but it need not be.
Jet Lag - 7 Steps To A Successful Trip
Don't let jet lag spoil that much needed holiday trip to paradise or stop you from closing that career enhancing deal you've been working on for months.Arriving full of excitement and anticipation is great, but finding that you can't sleep at night, you're tired during the day and you've got an upset stomach and a headache can do a lot more than just take the edge off your trip.
Sport Aviation and Jet Aircraft
Do you want a little business jet with a lot of power? Well hold on, as we are almost here. There are many new little Biz Jets about to come to the market place.
Secrets to Finding Really Cheap Airline Tickets Online
Knowing where to find really cheap airline tickets is the first step to shopping for the best airfares online but once you've overcome this little hurdle on your race to getting really cheap airline tickets you'll need to know how to book the cheapest airfares.Let's say you've found a great website that offers really cheap airline tickets online - like lastminutetravel.
Fuel Costs and Air Fares Set To Rocket After Hurricane Katrina Punishes The US
It now looks certain that Hurricane Katrina will push fuel prices - and air fares - up through the roof.Hurricane Katrina has just killed hundreds of people, and it could well be thousands of people that we don't know about already.
Jet Lag - 5 In-flight Tips
The secret to combating jet lag, and arriving at your destination with little or no jet lag, lies in sound preparation well in advance of your date of travel. This, however, is only the foundation of your "anti jet lag" plan and all of your sound preparatory work will be wasted if you don't also ensure that you follow a sensible routine during your flight.
Finding Really Cheap Airline Tickets Online
Trying to find really cheap airline tickets can become very frustrating and time consuming but if you know how and where to search you can quickly and easily find airline tickets online.The internet is fast become the best place to find really cheap airline ticket deals.
Airport Travel Tips: Reducing Waiting Times
Key Travel TipsFollowing these tips will help you reduce your wait time at the security checkpoint.Before you go to the Airport? Do not pack or bring Prohibited Items to the airport.
Inflatable Aircraft Wing Camber Modification
Every aircraft is a compromise. It is either built to fly fast or slow to land in tight distances and carry more weight.
Mirrors to Redirect Mini Laser Weapons on Fighters for Vortex Airflows
Recently a new airborne laser system was announced to be put onto fighter jets, once this technology becomes more advanced we will no longer need missiles for air-to-air combat. The system, which will go onto a fighter jet would be called the; "HELLADS" or High Energy Liquid Laser Area Defense System, it is being tested now.
Fighter Jet Trainers Sport Planes
You want a fighter jet as your personal aircraft; do not deny it. You want to travel faster than the speed of sound and play Top Gun in the sky.
Young Men Trying to Imitate the 9-11 Scenario, Part III
What caused a teenager to crash an aircraft into the Bank of America Building in Tampa? It makes no sense. Read more in Part III to try to understand the causes involved in this scenario.
NASA SATS for Point-to-Point Air Travel Solutions
It appears NASA's studies of the future of air travel and air taxi concepts. By studying these possible futures we may find our selves ready to accept flying cars in everyone's garage.
Laser Beam Guidance for Oshkosh Air Show
The Federal Aviation Administration is devising a method of alerting pilots who enter a restricted airspace to leave immediately. To do this is will use a laser beam pointed at the aircraft in a certain color.
FAA Intervention in Privatized Space Flight is Ridiculous
Burt Rutan and his team of designers, engineers and test pilots at Scaled Composites did something no private group had ever done. They proved that private space flight is feasible and safe.
Entering Business Aviation, Part II: Pay Rates for Flight Attendants
Pay. You know that aviation pays better than commercial, in most cases a lot better, but you aren't sure what the going rate is for a corporate flight attendant.
New Airbus A-380 Beats Out 747
The A-380 has beat out the Boeing 747 as a target by International Terrorists. The A-380 will become the largest passenger jet in the world holding the largest number of passengers.
American Airlines; Crash: Nov. 12, 2001
It seems there were not many comments to the AA crash of November 2001, as soon as it was ruled an accident instead of an attack the media stopped the reports and the story disappeared. The years following have been the safest years in Airline Industry History.

More Aviation Information:

Related Articles

Travel Tips:Tips for Safer flying
Flying can be an adventure, but like everything else in life, there are small risks. Even though flying is the safest way to travel in this modern age, here are some tips to minimize any unfortunate, but unlikely event of an emergency situation.
Entering Business Aviation, Part V: Tips on Finding Work
I will not pretend that this is the easiest topic to write about. In fact, my knowledge of how one finds work as a private flight attendant is based chiefly on what others have shared with me.
Preventing Rapid Decompression In Commercial Airliners
In Flight Airline Rapid Decompression Breached Window(Airline Safety)Here is a concept worthy of mention about the issues concerning Airline International Terrorists and Guns in the Cockpit and of course Federal Air Marshals. If a gun goes off in a smaller airliner, 737 or 767 then a bullet could penetrate a window and breach the pressurization system.
Several Facts to Obtaining Cheap Airfares
AirfaresNeed a vacation but dont want to stay around town? Want to go somewhere exotic, somewhere different? Want to fly but worried about the airfare? Sourcing the cheapest airfare available has been made easier with competition growing between travel agencies as people realize that a vacation need not be all that expensive. Airfare can be a hindrance to the best of vacation plans but it need not be.
De Ice Boots Preventative Care
If you have de-ice boots on your aircraft you realize that for them to last you will need to keep them in new condition. In days gone buy aviators and aircraft mechanics have used all sorts of things to keep them in mint condition.
Getting Cheap Airfares
Airlines offer tickets at a fraction of the cost you buy tickets. These offers are given to wholesalers and agencies that bring good business to them.
Young Men Trying to Imitate the 9-11 Scenario, Part II
What happened to General Aviation after 9-11? Why did we take the ITC away in the late 80's? Why were we hostile with IRS regulations toward Civil Air Patrol pilot owners? What else did this cause and why is it significant to this Part II of aviation mentor-ships for young men? We continue now with Part II of "Young Men trying to imitate the 9-11 Scenario."Wichita KS boomed due to the Ivestment Tax Credit regulations and the city had lots of population to draw from for mechanics, since so many people worked in the aviation factories.
Downed Pilots Hibernating From the Enemy
When we watch Oliver North's "War Stories" or the "Wings Discovery Channel" we often see the problematic issues with downed pilots trying to evade the enemy. They have limited if any food supply and lots of people looking for them.
NASA SATS for Point-to-Point Air Travel Solutions
It appears NASA's studies of the future of air travel and air taxi concepts. By studying these possible futures we may find our selves ready to accept flying cars in everyone's garage.
Airbus to Build $600 Million Aircraft Manufacturing Plant in US
Airbus has announced that it will build a $600 million aircraft manufacturing plant in Mobile Alabama. This is significant news and will open doors to US based commercial airlines to buy more Airbus Aircraft in the future.
Airline Fuel Costs Mount
The airlines are huge users of fuel. Fuel costs are higher than even the cost of the aircraft.
Airlines, Price Wars, and Branding
Here are some thoughts on the study of the theory of price wars as they relate to the industries like the Airlines and others. Comments on an article in Harvard Business Review in March-April edition 2000.
Fighter Jet Trainers Sport Planes
You want a fighter jet as your personal aircraft; do not deny it. You want to travel faster than the speed of sound and play Top Gun in the sky.
The History of the Aircraft Wash Guys, Part Two
The continuation of the history of a small service franchise business in the aviation sector; whose humble beginnings began in the middle of a recession. This proves that anything is possible and that with enough will and entrepreneurial spirit no matter what the condition of your industry sector, you can succeed in America.
How to Save on Airfare
The Internet has provided a revolution in the way people shop for airfares. What used to be the province only of connected travel agents is now the province of every Internet connected traveler.
5 Tips for Stress Free Long Haul Flights
The world is becoming smaller by the day. Flying long haul to distant locations for business or pleasure is becoming increasingly more popular.
Jet Lag - You Can Suffer From It...Or You Can Do What This International Airline Captain Does
Whatever the reason for your travel, you have made a considerable investment. It costs you time and money.
The History of the Aircraft Wash Guys, Part Three
As we study this grass roots history of a franchise company in the making we see how opportunity in the market grows companies and how entrepreneurial thinkers take advantage of those opportunities to deliver goods and services, which match the desires of the market place. In this review of the history of the aircraft wash guys we see the company diversifying and finding other niches to serve, some of which were actually better than the original plan.
Concorde Crash Conspiracy - It Could Have Been Prevented
In studying the Concorde crash the investigators determined it was caused by debris on the runway, which had fallen off a Continental Airlines Aircraft, which went down the same runway prior to the Concorde. Some thought the crash was an International Terrorist Attack.
Flying With Your Dog
A pet owner must research the many requirements before taking a dog on an airplane. Different airlines have slightly different regulations, but most airlines follow the same basic set of rules in regards to flying with a dog.