The Quite Coup of the Courts


By Jeff Dunetz

There is a constitutional crisis in this country. One branch of government is undermining the rule of law.

The culprit isn't President Trump or Congress; it's the courts. Nationwide, judges are making public policy, rather than adjudicating it. This power grab is apparent in immigration cases, where judges have ignored the Constitution and issued rulings based on personal beliefs.

This arrogation of power should worry liberals, conservatives, and moderates alike.

Consider recent rulings that block President Trump from ending President Obama's Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals program. DACA offers work permits and temporary legal status to 690,000 illegal immigrants who came to the United States as minors.

The creation of DACA by the executive branch contravenes constitutional separation of powers and violates Congressional statutes. Given the chance to pass legislation, Democratic supermajorities in Congress considered, and then rejected an amnesty for young illegal aliens in 2010.

For most of his first term, President Obama acknowledged he couldn't "just bypass Congress and change the law myself... That's not how a democracy works."

But in 2012, President Obama changed his mind. He argued that unilateral action was the "right thing to do" and he exempted certain illegal aliens from immigration law and began illegally granting them work permits.

President Trump campaigned against DACA and last fall he announced his decision to end the program. Unilateral executive action can be reversed, especially when the President finds his predecessor's actions to be unconstitutional.

But some activist judges felt differently.

William Alsup, a district court judge in San Francisco, issued a nationwide injunction that prevented the administration from ending DACA. His ruling asserted "that the public interest will be served by DACA's continuation."

Nicholas Garaufis, a district court judge in Brooklyn, issued his own politically-charged injunction. The judge condemned the DACA roll-back as "heartless."

The judges nullified the president's order not because it was unlawful -- but because they personally disagreed with it.

Judges also relied on emotion to impede President Trump's travel ban, which prohibited visitors and immigrants from a handful of majority-Muslim nations, Venezuela, and North Korea.

The Constitution gives the president latitude to deny foreigners entrance into the country. In 1950, the Supreme Court noted that "The exclusion of aliens is a fundamental act of sovereignty... inherent in the executive power."

Five previous presidents barred certain foreigners from entering the country. Even President Obama temporarily prevented Iraqi refugees from entering in 2011.

But judges repeatedly slapped injunctions on the travel ban. This February, the Fourth Circuit Court claimed that the president's supposed animus towards Muslims invalidates his authority.

The Supreme Court overturned the lower courts' rulings and narrowly upheld the ban with a 5-4 decision.

The Constitution prevailed—this time.

Judicial activism should worry Americans of all political affiliations. Even liberals.

By cheering on judicial overreach now, they risk looking like hypocrites later if extremely conservative judges appointed by President Trump strike down reproductive rights, safety net programs, and legal protections for disadvantaged groups based on personal beliefs.

Courts are supposed to decide whether Congress and the president's policies are constitutional -- not whether they're wise or compassionate. The devolution from judicial review to judicial supremacy bodes ill for our republic.

Jeff Dunetz is publisher of The Lid (LidBlog.com), a political columnist at The Jewish Star, and host of the weekly Lid Radio.

More Resources


03/28/2024
The Democrats' Abundance Problem Revisited
Last week, I started revisiting my "Three Point Plan to Fix the Democrats and Their Coalition" from October of 2022. A brisk tour of the polling and political data suggested the Democrats are still in need of serious reform and that the three point plan is as relevant as ever. Here's the very short version of the plan:

more info


03/28/2024
Are Democrats Still Stuck With Biden?
Voters don't think much of the president but also remain wary of the obvious replacement.

more info


03/28/2024
What the Polls Say: RFK Jr. Hurting Biden, Helping Trump
In October, when Robert F. Kennedy Jr. abandoned his primary challenge to Joe Biden and instead launched an independent candidacy, the initial conventional wisdom was that he might hurt Donald Trump more than Biden.

more info


03/28/2024
The Twilight of the Republican 'McLeadership'
The Trump team is steadily purging the Republican leadership of holdovers from past decades. The departure of McCarthy, McDaniel, and McConnell is part of exorcising the legacy of a more important Mc whose influence is still felt in the U.S. Senate: John McCain.

more info


03/28/2024
The Funniest Media Story of the Year?
The following three things were obvious before MSNBC puked on itself in its public divorce with former RNC chief Ronna McDaniel, but aren't we glad the network didn't notice? More later, but briefly:

more info


03/28/2024
Abridging, Not Coercing, Is First Amendment's Yardstick
Under the First Amendment, the government may not abridge the freedom of speech, whether that abridging is done by coercing internet platforms or by getting them to cooperate in government efforts to censor the public.

more info


03/28/2024
Trade Cheaters Are Killing Aluminum Industry Jobs
Aluminum industry workers stand ready to do their part to move the nation forward. They just need the federal government to enforce trade laws.

more info


03/28/2024
It's Time for an Immigration Moratorium
An effective freeze on immigration could revitalize our national culture, politics, and economy before it's too late.

more info


03/28/2024
U.N. Gaza Resolution Could Lead to Lasting Cease-Fire
After 171 days of a relentless Israeli assault on Gaza, the United Nations Security Council approved a resolution calling for a cease-fire in Gaza, with the United States abstaining. It's a breakthrough that must be built upon.

more info


03/28/2024
Biden's War Against the Jews
Biden claims he is a lifelong friend of the Jewish people and a Zionist, but these empty words are cover for a decades-long antipathy

more info


03/28/2024
'Fairness Initiative' Tackles Too-High Government Pay
Governments at every level ought to cap public-sector wages and benefits at private-sector comparables.

more info


03/28/2024
My Friend Joe
I write now, in the worst pain and shock, with news of my friend Joe Lieberman's death just moments ago. I write because I know what his critics will be quick to write, what news reports have already re-circulated.

more info


03/28/2024
Why I'm Resigning From the Biden State Department
Since Hamas' attack on October 7, Israel has used American bombs in its war in Gaza, which has killed more than 32,000 people - 13,000 of them children - with countless others buried under the rubble, according to the Gaza Ministry of Health. Israel is credibly accused of starving the 2 million people who remain, according to the UN special rapporteur on the right to food; a group of charity leaders warns that without adequate aid, hundreds of thousands more will soon likely join the dead.

more info


03/28/2024
Gaza: Truths Behind All the Lies
From civilian casualties, the use of disproportionate force, and international biases, the mainstream narrative of the Gaza conflict often obfuscates the truth behind lies.

more info


03/28/2024
Obama, Fearing Biden Loss to Trump, Is On Phone To Strategize
As the election approaches, President Joe Biden is making regular calls to former President Barack Obama to catch up on the race or to talk about family. But Obama is making calls of his own to Jeffrey Zients, the White House chief of staff, and to top aides at the Biden campaign to strategize and relay advice.

more info



Custom Search

More Politics Articles:

Related Articles

Speaker Pelosi's Drug Plan Misses the Mark


House Speaker Nancy Pelosi just proposed one of the most ambitious healthcare reforms since the Affordable Care Act. She hopes her plan, The Lower Drug Costs Now Act, will reduce the "out of control" prices that are "crushing Americans at the pharmacy counter."

The Soviet-Afghan War at Forty:


In the early morning hours of Christmas Day 1979, Soviet forces began invading Afghanistan. The international community was shocked by the intervention; even though Afghanistan had been unstable for some time, most assumed that the Soviet Union would stick to its usual policy of indirect aid. Soviet policymakers, however, had several reasons for taking action when they did, including the deterioration of détente with the United States, alarm at the Afghan regime's behavior, the desire to replace President Hafizullah Amin with a more pliable ruler, fears of foreign interference in Afghanistan, and national security concerns.

Brexit: What Is at Stake?


I feel badly for the people of the United Kingdom. Brexit — the move to withdraw the UK from the European Union — has left the United Kingdom anything but united. Even families are being ripped apart. The most notable involves Prime Minister Boris Johnson's own family. His brother Jo (a fine fellow whom I met several years ago) resigned his seat in Parliament and his place in his brother's cabinet because he wanted to remain and Boris wants to leave.

Klein v. Oregon: Religious Liberty and Freedom of Speech vs. Gay Rights


Among recent actions by the U.S. Supreme Court, a four-sentence order may set the stage for the court to eventually address the collision between free speech and religious freedom on one hand and gay rights on the other. The order voided a judgment by the state of Oregon that had imposed a $135,000 fine on Portland-area bakery owners—the Kleins—for refusing to bake a wedding cake for a lesbian couple. Oregon maintained that its anti-discrimination law condemned such a rebuff even when the bakery owners' religious convictions run counter to participating in a same-sex wedding.

Holidays and Politics: Rebuilding Civility


With the chill in the air and the leaves already falling, the holidays are just around the corner. Whether you're hosting or being hosted, the old rule of not discussing religion, money, or politics serves as a reminder of the issues which can divide even those who love each other the most. But in an era where everything, from ice cream to music, is politicized, avoiding political topics in conversation with those of differing views becomes almost impossible. Is this overly divisive and ever-present political tension healthy for society?

Addressing Out-of-Pocket Costs Key to Health Improvement & Cost Savings


More than 190 million Americans suffer from chronic diseases. For them, healthcare reform isn't a political football -- it's a matter of life and death.

Pipeline Hate Is Misplaced


Sixteen-year-old Swedish student Greta Thunberg admonished global leaders at last year's United Nations: "We are in the beginning of a mass extinction, and all you can talk about is money and fairy tales of eternal economic growth. How dare you!"

Trump's New Drug Pricing Plan Isn't "The Best Deal" For Patients


President Trump will soon unveil a new plan to reduce drug prices.

With Coronavirus, Trump White House Should Revive Drug Rebate Reform


High out of pocket costs likely won't be an issue when a treatment for the coronavirus becomes available. Based on past epidemics, it's probable the government will direct patients to receive a vaccine without having to hand over a copay to an insurance company.

Thank This Obscure Law for a Potential Coronavirus Vaccine


According to the Milken Institute, over 70 treatments for COVID-19 are already in clinical trials or progressing toward clinical trials. Several of the inventions behind this flurry of activity resulted from government funded research in U.S. universities.

America Needs Non-Profits Now More Than Ever


The COVID-19 pandemic has brought the country to a crawl. Lawmakers and consumers alike are rightly worried about the economic security of shuttered bars, restaurants, and retail locations. But many have largely ignored the nation's charities.

Washington Wants to Forfeit Our Best Weapon Against Coronavirus


Rep. Jan Schakowsky (D-IL) and several senior House lawmakers recently announced a plan to impose price controls and seize patents on any COVID-19 vaccines and treatments in development. They vowed to strike down any emergency stimulus packages excluding such measures.

Crack Down on China—But Do It Wisely


The Chinese Communist Party poses a dire threat to America and the rest of the free world. Party leadership actively covered up the initial coronavirus outbreak -- and even persecuted doctors who tried to warn the public. China's leaders hoarded masks and other medical supplies, which resulted in shortages of personal protective equipment in the United States.

Helping Unemployed Americans


Unemployed Americans need cash. We go to work in return for a paycheck. With unemployment we lose the paycheck. It's a simple but very painful formula for millions of Americans.

The Problem with Inheritance Taxes


A recent opinion piece in The New York Times, "Tax the Rich and Their Heirs — more fairly," was both reassuring and refreshing. It was reassuring to know that policy debates about relatively prosaic public policy issues continue to be debated, even though the country is convulsed with violent unrest and pandemic-related stresses. It is refreshing that the tone of the writer, New York University law professor Lily Batchelder, was measured and civil at a time when so much writing is shrill and strident.