It's Time to Turn the Prescription Drug Debate on its Head


By Kenneth E. Thorpe

Politicians typically blame drug companies for soaring pharmacy prices. But insurers, pharmacies, and other middlemen are the real driving force behind rising drug spending.

These groups are incentivized to push for high sticker prices, as they're often able to keep the rebates and discounts they negotiate. Until political leaders address this perverse incentive, America's sickest patients will continue struggling to afford their medicines.

Americans spent almost $440 billion on brand-name drugs in 2018, up from around $269 billion in 2013. That's a 64 percent increase.

But those extra billions didn't all, or even mostly, flow to research companies or their shareholders. The share of spending on branded medicines that ended up in drug companies' coffers dropped by 12.5 percentage points between 2013 and 2018. So where is the money going? To other entities in the pharmaceutical supply chain.

Insurers take a big chunk. Another portion flows to pharmacy benefit managers, the companies hired by insurers to design and administer their drug benefits. Together, these and other third-party groups pocket about half of all brand-name spending. PBMs decide which drugs an insurance plan will -- and won't -- cover. This negotiating leverage enables them to extract hefty discounts from drug makers. Pharmaceutical companies offered up $166 billion in rebates and discounts in 2018.

Patients rarely receive these rebates, at least not directly. PBMs pocket a small share of the rebates, and pass the rest along to the insurers that hired them. Insurers use these savings to offer cheaper monthly premiums to all beneficiaries. Lower premiums are a good thing, of course. But spread across tens of millions of people, these massive discounts only translate into a few dollars per beneficiary per month.

That's little help to patients with chronic conditions, many of whom rely on multiple prescriptions to stay healthy. In addition to their monthly premiums, these patients owe a co-pay or co-insurance fee every time they pick up or refill a prescription. And insurers base these cost-sharing payments on a drug's inflated sticker price, not the heavily discounted price secured by PBMs.

In other words, the status quo burdens the sickest patients with high out-of-pocket costs while slightly reducing monthly premiums for healthier beneficiaries.

This arrangement is counterproductive. Close to half of Americans in fair or poor health struggle to afford their medicines. Roughly three in 10 don't take their medicines as prescribed for financial reasons.

That needs to change. If insurers and PBMs passed along all rebates to patients through lower co-pays and co-insurance, individuals with diabetes could save $3.7 billion each year on insulin alone. That's close to $800 per patient. Lawmakers from both parties want to reduce patients' pharmacy bills. It's time for Washington to turn its attention to the real source of high drug costs.

Kenneth E. Thorpe is a professor of health policy at Emory University and chairman of the Partnership to Fight Chronic Disease.

More Resources


03/29/2024
2024, an Election About Elections
The new poll out from Fox News has a number of intriguing findings.

more info


03/29/2024
The Overlooked Truths About Biden's Age
In terms of optics and in terms of energy, I wish President Biden were younger. There's no point in pretending

more info


03/29/2024
Biden, Obama & Clinton Join Forces in NY
Thursday on the RealClearPolitics radio show (Monday through Friday at 6:00 p.m. EDT on SiriusXM's P.O.T.U.S. Channel 124), Carl Cannon, Tom Bevan and Emily Jashinsky discuss: Joe Lieberman's passing, Bobby Kennedy Jr.'s appeal to voters, the environment of victimization culture, Sam Bankman-Fried's 25-year prison sentence, and James Carville's riff on "preachy" Democrats.

more info


03/29/2024
Meddlers for RFK Jr.
Democrats may get bitten by a tactic they use to great effect in GOP primaries.

more info


03/29/2024
Will RFK Jr.'s Support for Israel Limit His Appeal on Left?
Robert F. Kennedy Jr.'s independent presidential campaign goes to considerable lengths to profess its potential appeal to people across the partisan and ideological landscape.

more info


03/29/2024
Joe Lieberman's Last Words on Israel
A warning to Biden that he risks losing the votes of Jewish Democrats like us.

more info


03/29/2024
A Senator Who Loved To Kibitz


more info


03/29/2024
Behind Scenes Stories of Censorship
Dave Rubin of "The Rubin Report" hosts a panel with the winners of the first RealClearPolitics Samizdat Prize -- "Twitter Files" journalist Matt Taibbi, "Great Barrington Declaration" co-author Dr. Jay Bhattacharya, and NY Post reporter and "Laptop From Hell" author Miranda Devine. The three were chosen for their bravery in resisting censorship. They discuss the cost of taking a stand as well as the future of free speech and online discourse.

more info


03/29/2024
Bidenomics Is Making China Angry. That's OK
A persistent theme in Republican campaigning these past few years has been the effort to portray Democrats in general, and

more info


03/29/2024
Biden's Boss Tightens the Screws


more info


03/29/2024
The Fight To Flip the House Just Got Harder for Dems


more info


03/29/2024
In 2024, Digital Is Everything in Politics


more info


03/29/2024
Comer Sums Up His 'Evidence' of Biden Crimes. It's Scant


more info


03/29/2024
WaPo's Lead Liar Waves Away Evidence of Biden Corruption
Glenn Kessler pretended to 'dissect' Rep. James Comer's comments but did not challenge any of the evidence the Republican mentioned.

more info


03/29/2024
Sam Bankman-Fried's Dream Came True


more info



Custom Search

More Politics Articles:

Related Articles

Armstrong Williams: Giving Back to the Industry He Loves
There's something to be said for the media gurus who immerse themselves in the whole industry.
Cut Low-Skilled Immigration to RAISE American Wages
The Senate could soon vote to give millions of Americans their biggest pay-raise in decades.
Trump undoes regulatory over-reach
President Trump is slowly but surely dismantling the "mare's nest" of regulations imposed by the Obama administration, says Dan Weber, president of the Association of Mature American Citizens.
Problems with a Carbon Tax
While President Donald Trump wants to cut taxes, there are others who hope to raise them -- by taxing carbon.
President Trump said, "They Are Losers"
President Trump has renamed terrorists from monsters to losers. I agree. People such as 22 year old Salmon Abedi who contrive to inflict such a heinous act as the carnage he recently inflicted in Manchester, England, is the worst of pathetic world losers.
The Fine Print on Pipelines Isn't Scary
Have you heard? Transporting oil through pipelines is a threat to humanity! The many accidents highlighted in the press speak for themselves.
President Needs to Tell the Ethanol Industry: You're Fired
President Donald Trump changed his mind on many issues since taking office -- China is no longer a currency manipulator and NATO is an important institution. So there's still hope he'll dump the renewable fuel standard (RFS).
Don't Play Favorites for Nuclear Energy
While critics bemoan President Trumps decision to pull out of -- or renegotiate -- the Paris climate agreement, the United States has been reducing its greenhouse gas emissions over the past decade. And now the country is poised to help a number of the signatory countries reduce theirs as well.
Should President Trump Quit?
Should President Donald Trump quit? A large percentage of Americans voted against him and continue to dislike him. About all of the Democrats in Congress are against him and there are certainly Republicans who aren't Trump fans. I was recently in France and there are plenty of people in that country who mock Trump. I would wager transgender people in the military don't like him. The protestors who show up wherever he is to protest, some of them paid to do so, don't like him.
Afghanistan - The End Is Not In Sight
October will mark the 16th year since President George W. Bush announced the first strikes against Afghanistan. In June 2010 we surpassed Vietnam as the longest conflict in U.S. history.
Don't Sanction Americans for Russia's Misdeeds
President Trump just signed a Russian sanctions bill into law -- and in doing so, narrowly avoided an economic catastrophe. Thanks to modifications to the bill's language by the House, Americans can rest easy knowing their economic future is protected.
Survey Says... Offshore Seismic is Safe
Late last month, Delaware Senators Tom Carper and Chris Coons released a statement opposing seismic surveying in the Atlantic Ocean. Their worry is that preparatory drilling work for oil and natural gas below the ocean floor would negatively impact marine life.
Changing Medicare Would Threaten Hispanics' Health
Hispanics are fifty percent more likely than whites to die from diabetes and liver disease.
A Money-Back Guarantee for Prescription Drugs
President Trump will soon issue an executive order to lower drug prices. The order likely will encourage federal health agencies to make greater use of "outcomes-based" contracts.
Requiring U.S.-Made Steel in Pipelines Would Backfire
President Trump has a plan to revive the steel industry. He wants to mandate that oil and natural gas pipelines use only American-made steel. His Commerce Department is finalizing the plan right now.
A poppy flower, red as blood, may help us acknowledge the new wars being fought in our own backyards
The world was a dangerous place during World War I. It was even more dangerous during World War II. And, it was frightening enough during the Cold War that ensued.
Democrats Dig for Russians and Uncover Environmentalists
Democrats and the media have been on a yearlong deep dig into Russian involvement into U.S. elections. But when you dig a hole you sometimes run across things you wish had remained buried—like the dirt pointing to Russian ties to the U.S. environmental movement.
The Energy Industry is Stepping up in the Wake of Hurricane Harvey
Hurricane Harvey struck the heart of America's energy sector. Greater Houston is home to dozens of refineries, pipelines, and petrochemical plants.
Taking Back Renewable Energy's Taxpayer-Funded Honeypot
The renewable energy industry exists because of government mandates and taxpayer subsidies.
The Political Intrigue of 1968—Fifty Years and Counting
My political interests were sparked at age 11, half a century ago, during one of the most interesting campaign seasons in recent American history. In my home we had neither a newspaper nor a news magazine. Our television reception was unreliable. Yet the stories were compelling. The favorite part of my day occurred when my bus arrived at school. I had 10 minutes to rush to the library and read the morning's editorials. Who knew I would be writing op-ed pieces as a hobby 50 years later?