Summer 2020 COVID-19 Data in Pennsylvania: What We Don't Know


By Dr. Gary Welton

The COVID-19 coronavirus is a novel virus, and everybody who claims they have it figured out is living under an illusion. Our knowledge is growing, but it is still very fragmented. Our local politicians have been cautious because of the vast unknown; we have never been here before.

Our educational leaders have been (and will be making) significant decisions about the new school year. What are the risks of returning to the traditional classroom? And what are the risks of not returning to the classroom? Because of the vast unknowns, the decision makers are operating in a largely and regrettably no-win scenario.

We know that the number of positive cases in the United States is up dramatically this summer. The number of deaths has also been growing, and every one of these individual deaths represents a heartbreaking story. Yet the escalating death rates are still well below the numbers from April and early May.

The Commonwealth of Pennsylvania experienced a very high number of cases and deaths in March and April but has not seen the dramatic summer spikes common in the southern states (though there are concerns about the recent spikes in Western Pennsylvania). The data, as represented in the below figure, show a change in the relationship between the number of new cases and the number of deaths in the last six weeks. The recent data points reflect both fewer cases and fewer deaths. If you look at the data through the spring, there was a very strong correlation between the number of new cases and the number of deaths, reaching a correlation as high as .92. Over the last three weeks, however, the correlation has approached zero (.07).

This raises the burning question, for which I wish we had the definitive answer, namely: Why?

Why are the death rates across the country much lower during a time when the number of new cases is skyrocketing? There are many potential answers, some of which are reassuring; others, not so much. It is likely that more than one of these factors is playing a role.

1. Many of the new cases are among younger Americans, for whom the risks have always been much lower.

2. We are using better strategies in our nursing homes than we used in the early months. Indeed, we are avoiding some horrific decisions in which nursing homes were required to accept COVID cases.

3. Medical data have shown that some of the ICU treatment protocols being used early on were simply wrong and made recovery less likely rather than more likely. We have learned from the data and changed treatment protocols as a result.

4. Just give it another week or two, and we might see the death rates soar.

5. The virus exists in various strains, some of which are more virulent than others. Many of the recent local cases may represent people infected with a weaker strain. This perspective has been suggested by Dr. Graham Snyder, University of Pittsburgh Medical Center medical director for infection prevention, during a press briefing. The weaker strain might indicate a mutation in the virus. It was indeed such a mutation that finally brought the flu pandemic of 1918 to an end.

6.The data include so many errors as to be unuseful.

Grove City College, where I am a professor, is located in Mercer County, a county that has seen a spike in new cases over the last several weeks. In fact, the number of new cases has doubled, and the county is considered to be a hot spot in the commonwealth. We still need to be diligent and careful in the way we live our lives.

While there are still many concerns, the data suggest that summer 2020 is less risky than the spring. Nevertheless, the risks continue. Be careful in how you read and understand the arguments that you see on social media. It is still a novel virus. Those who make dogmatic statements (from whatever perspective) will likely be shown to be wrong.

We have been told in our state to wear face masks, and it does appear that more people are doing so. Nevertheless, many people are wearing them incorrectly (not covering their noses, for example), and many are removing them when they speak (and hence when the risks of transmission are higher).

The current data are promising, yet still concerning. Ultimately, history may show which of the six explanations (or perhaps some seventh one) turns out to be most accurate. Some of these predict improving results; some predict deteriorating scenarios. Until we have that historical perspective, caution is still required.

Every morning I pray, "Lord, help me not to behave in a way that makes this situation worse for even one other person. Let me be part of the solution; not part of the problem."

Dr. Gary L. Welton is assistant dean for institutional assessment, professor of psychology at Grove City College, and a contributor to the Institute for Faith & Freedom. He is a recipient of a major research grant from the Templeton Foundation to investigate positive youth development.

More Resources


03/29/2024
2024, an Election About Elections
The new poll out from Fox News has a number of intriguing findings.

more info


03/29/2024
The Overlooked Truths About Biden's Age
In terms of optics and in terms of energy, I wish President Biden were younger. There's no point in pretending

more info


03/29/2024
Biden, Obama & Clinton Join Forces in NY


more info


03/29/2024
Meddlers for RFK Jr.


more info


03/29/2024
Will RFK Jr.'s Support for Israel Limit His Appeal on Left?


more info


03/29/2024
Joe Lieberman's Last Words on Israel


more info


03/29/2024
A Senator Who Loved To Kibitz


more info


03/29/2024
Behind Scenes Stories of Censorship


more info


03/29/2024
Bidenomics Is Making China Angry. That's OK
A persistent theme in Republican campaigning these past few years has been the effort to portray Democrats in general, and

more info


03/29/2024
Biden's Boss Tightens the Screws


more info


03/29/2024
The Fight To Flip the House Just Got Harder for Dems


more info


03/29/2024
In 2024, Digital Is Everything in Politics


more info


03/29/2024
Comer Sums Up His 'Evidence' of Biden Crimes. It's Scant


more info


03/29/2024
WaPo's Lead Liar Waves Away Evidence of Biden Corruption
Glenn Kessler pretended to 'dissect' Rep. James Comer's comments but did not challenge any of the evidence the Republican mentioned.

more info


03/29/2024
Sam Bankman-Fried's Dream Came True


more info



Custom Search

More Politics Articles:

Related Articles

The Interational Fix to Rural America's Healthcare Crisis


Imagine going into cardiac arrest and the closest emergency room is more than 30 miles away. Or suppose your child is struggling with depression, but there isn't a single psychiatrist in your county. Or consider experiencing unexpected pregnancy complications -- yet living hours away from a hospital that has the resources to help.

We Need Health Care Reforms That Help Patients, Families


This summer, we saw remarkable, bipartisan progress on addressing rising health care costs -- an issue voters have consistently ranked as most important.

The Strategic Effect of Operation Kayla


Raids, like Operation Kayla resulting in the death of Abu-Bakr al-Baghdadi and other ISIS terrorist leaders, are usually small affairs with limited results. Nevertheless, such meticulously planned and superbly executed raids also can have significant strategic implications.

Save the Electoral College: The Founders Warned of an "'Overbearing Majority"


An apparent new litmus test has appeared among the 2020 Democratic presidential hopefuls: abolishing the Electoral College.

A Lot Less Bluster and a Little More Sasse


Predictably, the start of Brett Kavanaugh's confirmation hearing to the Supreme Court was an embarrassing fiasco for almost everyone involved. The Republican chair of the Judiciary Committee, Senator Chuck Grassley, had barely begun his opening remarks before Democratic Senator Kamala Harris interrupted to demand the meeting be adjourned, and less than two minutes in protestors started screaming. Protestors continued to interrupt the hearing, which was mostly just senatorial demagoguery on camera anyway, for the next four hours or so. There are many reasons for this: the stakes are high, everything connected with President Trump is radioactive, and the midterms are just two months away. But hours into a series of diatribes from senators on both sides of the aisle, Senator Ben Sasse from Nebraska took a different approach.

Pelosi's Drug Scheme Robs Patients of Tomorrow's New Medicines


The House of Representatives passed Speaker Nancy Pelosi's unprecedented crackdown on the pharmaceutical industry. Her bill, "H.R.3," would allow the government to dictate prices on a broad array of drugs, with the promise of bringing domestic prices closer to those in foreign countries with government-run healthcare systems.

The High Cost of the White House's Drug Pricing Plan


The Trump administration will soon roll out a new plan to slash drug prices.

Are You Tired of Watching America's Natural Landscapes Disappear?


America's population is soaring. Our nation currently houses 330 million people. And each year, that number grows by 2 million. By 2065, more than 440 million people may call the United States home.

End Foreign Freeloading - Don't Import It


Since day one in office, President Trump has been eager to put America first -- even when it has meant upending norms, upsetting political allies, and straining relationships abroad. This eagerness is worth applauding.

Correcting This Faulty Belief About COVID-19 Will Save Lives


In times of emergency, misperceptions can prove deadly. That's certainly the case today, amid widespread belief that COVID-19 mainly threatens older Americans.

Congress Plans to Steal the Coronavirus Vaccine


Lawmakers in Washington want to confiscate the patents on coronavirus treatments and vaccines -- before biotech companies even finish developing them.

We Don't Need an Economic Collapse to Curb Emissions
COVID-19 has caused a worldwide economic collapse. Yet some radical environmentalists are celebrating.

A Little-Known Law Gave Birth to Google -- and Countless Other Inventions


When Google founders Larry Page and Sergey Brin spoke to my colleagues at Stanford's technology licensing office in the late 1990s, other search engines already existed.

Whose Life Doesn't Matter?


I understand and affirm that black lives matter. Some of my dearest friends are black people. I love them and they matter. There are many black people, who I do not know, but they matter just the same.

Trump Administration Ends Pharmacy Coupons When Patients Need Them Most


For chronically ill Americans, the economic damage from COVID-19 could be nearly as life-threatening as the virus itself. More than 40 million workers have filed for unemployment since the beginning of the outbreak. For many, the financial challenges of joblessness have made it harder than ever to afford their insurance companies' medication copays.