Carson v. Makin: A Trilogy of Cases Protecting Religious Liberty, Completed


By John A. Sparks


In 2017, the Supreme Court decided a case that involved a school playground resurfacing program provided by the state of Missouri. Trinity Lutheran School sought a state grant, which was generally offered to other schools, but Trinity was denied funding solely because it was a religious school. The Supreme Court found in favor of the school, saying that it had every right, under the free exercise clause of the First Amendment, to participate in a government benefit program without giving up its religious affiliation.

In 2020, the high court continued efforts to return the free exercise clause to the strength the Americans founders intended. The case was Espinoza v. Montana. Montana gave tax credits to donors who created scholarships for private schools, but the state refused to allow parents who received scholarships to put them toward tuition at religious schools. The Supreme Court found against Montana, saying that requiring a school “to divorce itself from any religious control or affiliation” in order to obtain the scholarship monies “deters or discourages the exercise of First Amendment rights.”

Now the new decision in Carson v. Makin, the third case in that trilogy of cases, again finds that a state-instituted program (this time in Maine) which “operates to identify and exclude otherwise eligible schools on the basis of their religious exercise” violates the free exercise clause of the First Amendment.

Here are the details: The state of Maine is the most rural state in the union. In some school districts, that resulted in too few students to financially justify the existence of a public secondary school. Consequently, Maine permitted those districts to provide a program of “tuition assistance” to families in those locations. One of the options open to parents was to choose a private school to which the publicly provided tuition monies would be sent. The Carson family and another family chose religious schools to which to send their children (Bangor Christian Schools and Temple Academy) because they lived in districts where no public secondary school existed and desired religious instruction as part of their children’s education.

Prior to 1981, the choice of a religiously affiliated school would have presented no problem, but in that year the state attorney general ruled that the practice could not continue because it amounted to “an establishment of religion.” The Maine legislature responded by requiring that tuition assistance payments, from then on, only go to “nonsectarian” schools, meaning those without a religious affiliation. The Carsons brought legal action and the case, after making its way through the lower courts, ended up before the U.S. Supreme Court.

In a 6-3 decision, the high court sided with the families and against the state of Maine. The court first addressed Maine’s claim that if tuition were to be paid to the religious schools, that would amount to an “establishment of religion.” The court pointed out that in a case decided in 2002, which involved a Cleveland, Ohio voucher program, it had already held that a benefit program under which private citizens “direct government aid to a religious schools wholly as a result of their own independent and private choice does not offend the Establishment Clause.” The court here once again recognized that indirect aid to religious schools, selected by parents, clearly was not equivalent to “an establishment of religion,” by which the founders meant a tax-supported, state-mandated church.

The majority opinion, written by the Chief Justice John Roberts, went on to identify the court’s cardinal principle that “a state violates the free exercise clause when it excludes religious observers from otherwise available public benefits.” Drawing on the Trinity playground and the Montana scholarship cases, Roberts says that though a state need not subsidize private education, if it does, it cannot disqualify some schools from those benefits because they are religious.

The Roberts’ opinion also disputes the claim by Justice Breyer that the court’s holding in favor of the families and against Maine runs contrary to “governmental neutrality” on religious matters. As Roberts points out, “there is nothing neutral about Maine’s program. The state pays tuition for certain students at private schools—so long as the schools are not religious. That is discrimination against religion.”

Maine’s exclusionary statutory language, which banned state aid to religious schools, harkens back to the “Blaine Amendments” named after Congressman James G. Blaine. At its height, over 30 states prevented public aid to “sectarian” schools. Originally, these provisions targeted Catholic schools, but more recently, they have targeted any religious school. The Roberts’ opinion effectively puts the final “nail in the coffin” of those types of provisions. States cannot disqualify private religious schools from being among the recipients of these public funds intended for education.

These three cases, because they widen the spectrum of parental educational choice, are especially important. Regrettably, many public schools and their boards have allowed their schools to drift into instruction that parents increasingly find runs counter to their convictions and values. This decision recognizes that parents desire and ought to have real educational alternatives.

Dr. John A. Sparks is the retired Dean of Arts & Letters, Grove City College and a Fellow in the Institute for Faith and Freedom. He is a member of the state bar of Pennsylvania and a graduate of Grove City College and the University of Michigan Law School. Sparks writes regularly for the Institute on Supreme Court developments.

More Resources


03/27/2024
Biden, Trump Know RFK Jr.'s VP Choice a Game Changer


more info


03/27/2024
Republican 'War on Women' Is a Media Myth
There's no evidence Republicans want to ban birth control. On the contrary, the GOP has led on efforts to make it easier to get birth control over the counter.

more info


03/27/2024
Supreme Court Scoffs at Flimsy Abortion Pill Argument


more info


03/27/2024
NBC's Failed Attempt To Appeal to MAGA Voters
I spent years in the MAGA cult: We loathed Ronna Romney McDaniel almost as much as we loathed the media

more info


03/27/2024
Democrats Are Better for the US Economy
Jeffrey Frankel notes that this is no mere correlation, though the cause remains an enduring puzzle.

more info


03/27/2024
TikTok's Dangerous Influence Over Kids
Congressional talk about TikTok needs to be a wake-up call to parents. The Chinese app exposes kids to dangerous content, especially about suicide. It's 'every parents's nightmare.'

more info


03/27/2024
Smartphones Rewired Childhood. Here's How to Fix It.
Phones have made kids sedentary, solitary, anxious, and depressed. But, says the author and psychologist, we can reverse the damage.

more info


03/27/2024
NBC Cements Status as Anti-Trump, Pro-Biden Network
The dramatic saga following NBC's announced hire of former RNC chair Ronna McDaniel solidified the network's position as being fully anti-Trump going into the 2024 election.

more info


03/27/2024
Don't Tell This 'Double-Hater' She's Crazy
Most of those known as 'double haters' will come around to support one of the two major party presidential nominees. But some, like Victoria Thompson, won't back Trump or Biden under any circumstances.

more info


03/27/2024
Joe Biden, the (Still) Unpopular President
There's been a lot of wishful reporting about the political fortunes and reelection hopes of President Joe Biden.

more info


03/27/2024
Trump's Crumbling Empire Gives Biden a Golden Opportunity
Here's a phrase I never thought I'd say: Donald Trump, Bible salesman.

more info


03/27/2024
Democrats Distort the Law To Subvert 2024 Election
An appeals court just gutted New York's $454 million fine against Trump in ‘a fraud case in which there are no fraud victims.'

more info


03/27/2024
RFK Jr. Makes New Play for Disaffected w/Nicole Shanahan
Mr. Kennedy's allies hope his choice of a wealthy Silicon Valley lawyer to be his running mate will inject new energy and financial support into his independent bid for the White House.

more info


03/27/2024
SCOTUS Must Rely on 1st Amendment Censorship Case
The justices of the Supreme Court never focused on the First Amendment's words when hearing arguments in Murthy v. Missouri last week. The case challenges the federal government's orchestration of social media censorship, so one might have expected the justices to pay some attention to the First Amendment itself.

more info


03/27/2024
The Republican House Fails the Ronald Reagan Test
Following its Friday failure to deliver a new package of aid for Ukraine, it's time for a title change in the US House of Representatives.

more info



Custom Search

More Politics Articles:

Related Articles

Should U.S. Energy Independence Be Based Only on Renewable Energy?


Last March President Donald Trump issued an executive order "promoting energy independence and economic growth." While he specifically included "renewable sources," he clearly intended to unleash the nation's massive fossil fuel resources, which is the only conceivable way to achieve energy independence —at least for the foreseeable future.

Trump's Monthly Box of Food for Our Poor


Back in the seventies my dad brought some delicious cheese home from our local town. "They were giving this cheese out in front of the courthouse so I picked some up" he said. The cheese was all part of the so called fight against poverty. My dad was a hard-working coal mining man so we had food to eat.

Guns, Opioids, Alcohol, Bad Judgment and Balance


Every person in America should have the privilege of driving a car if they meet the qualifications. Requirements involve passing written and driving tests and passing a vision test. Enough incidents of driving violations or driving impaired can certainly curtail and even eliminate our privilege to drive an automobile.

Easter - America Needs a Good Story


Americans are waiting and hoping. We're hoping for something and we aren't exactly for sure what we are hoping for. Internally it's always the hopes of something better around the corner.

AMAC calls for Repeal of the Medicare Anti-Kickback Safe Harbor Statute


The Association of Mature American Citizens [AMAC] has issued a call for its members and other concerned seniors to press their lawmakers, on both sides of the aisle, to repeal the Medicare Anti-Kickback Safe Harbor Statute.

Gas and Oil Re-Invest Tax Windfall


President Trump's recent tax overhaul has American CEOs feeling generous. Walmart and American Airlines are among the big companies giving employees bonuses of up to $1,000 each; Lockheed Martin is putting an additional $5 million toward employee pensions, and Cigna is upping its hourly minimum wage to $16.

Secretary Perry's Coal Bailout Is a Raw Deal for Taxpayers


An independent government agency saved Americans from a massive de facto tax hike.

Russian Trolls are Pitting Americans Against Energy Industry


According to a March report from the House Science, Space and Technology Committee, Russian trolls are trying to disrupt U.S. energy markets.

"Speech Police" Roam America's College Campuses


A German woman who survived the holocaust says it's reminiscent of the Nazis

Colorado's "Half-Baked" Decision Nixed by the Supreme Court


At the U.S. Supreme Court on Monday, Justice Anthony Kennedy delivered a long-awaited opinion concerning Jack Phillips, the Christian baker who owns Masterpiece Cakeshop located in Lakewood, Colorado, west of Denver. Kennedy and the court ruled in favor of Phillips, 7-2.

The Free Market Is Curing Blindness


The FDA recently approved a revolutionary drug that could restore sight to 2,000 nearly-blind Americans.

Blockchain Could Save Federal Agencies Billions


It's hard to misplace $800 million. Yet the Pentagon recently did. The Defense Logistics Agency, which manages military construction projects, lost track of enough money to fill two tractor trailers with $20 bills, according to an internal audit leaked in February.

Strengthen Patents to Boost Family Businesses


Which company is more innovative? A corporate giant, or a family-owned business?

Branson Duck Boat Ride — Bad Judgment


I've thought about taking a Duck boat ride and I'm glad I passed.

Animal Lovers Should Be Cheering For Animal Research — Not Opposing It.


Scientists just discovered a drug that could save millions of dogs -- and humans -- from cancer. Veterinarians at Tufts University administered the experimental treatment to Dover, a 7-year old dog suffering from lymphoma. The cancer had caused him to go blind, and his days were numbered. In desperation, Dover's owner enrolled him in a clinical trial testing the early-stage therapy.

Global Leaders Dither While Disease Races to Latin America


You're nearly twice as likely to die from colon cancer living in a Latin American country than you are living in the United States.

Trump Claims He's Defending U.S. Companies — But Businesses Disagree


This summer, President Trump imposed a 25-percent tariff on $34 billion of Chinese goods. The move follows his June levies on steel and aluminum from Canada, Mexico, and Europe.

Right to Try Provides a License to Cash In on Patient Fears


More than 1.7 million Americans will be diagnosed with cancer this year. One in three of those patients will eventually succumb to it.

Marching for Life: Countering Roe V. Wade's Escorts


I saw them again a few weeks ago, the first time in a while. My wife and I were driving by. They stood outside the Planned Parenthood clinic in Pittsburgh. "Look," I said to my wife, "those are the so-called 'escorts.' They lead young women into the abortion clinic. Look at their smiles as they do their job."

Medicare for All Means Medicare for No One: Cautionary Tales from Abroad


Cheryl Gilarski has had enough health problems to last a lifetime.