The Nuclear Superpowers and True Self-Interest


By Winslow Myers


A number of nuclear strategy experts have agreed that the only sensible response to China’s alarming new buildup of nuclear weapons is for the U.S. itself to build more and better weapons. The apparent purpose of this buildup on our part is first to ensure that our deterrent is ironclad, and second it is argued as the only viable way to force the Chinese (and perhaps even the Russians, eventually) to the arms control table. After all, it worked before, when President Reagan outspent the Russians and helped end the first cold war.

There are three factors suggesting that this supposedly thoughtful establishment policy is performatively contradictory and growing more so year by year, decade by decade.

First, there is the dark paradox of having the weapons at the ready on hair-trigger precisely so that they will never be used. It is already a kind of miracle that we have been able to make it through decades of nuclear confrontation without making a fatal mistake (though the catalog of known near-misses is profoundly sobering); how much longer can our good fortune last? As the delivery vehicles move from supersonic to hypersonic, windows of decision become ever smaller and opportunities for misinterpretation ever larger.

Second, nuclear winter. Carefully designed computer models predict that it would only take about a hundred detonations over large cities to raise tons of soot into the upper atmosphere sufficient to cause a global freeze that would destroy most agriculture for a decade. This inconvenient truth not only cancels out any advantage afforded by competitive numbers of warheads but also throws deterrence strategy in general into disarray. If one hundred weapons can kill the planet, what’s the point of thousands more?

And third, opportunity costs. Together, the three superpowers are planning trillions in spending to upgrade their arsenals both in terms of quantity and “quality” (reliability, speed, ease of launch, variety, precision etc.) when the world is crying out for funds to feed the starving, find homes for refugees, vaccinate against Covid, get beyond fossil fuels, and heal a degraded environment.

If nuclear weapons could resolve the present tensions over Taiwan and in Ukraine, someone would presumably already have used them. But we all know that these weapons are completely useless as part of a winning military strategy. The game is up, but because of the international obsession with credibility, the game continues, no matter how meaningless, crazy, immoral, criminal, silly, and stupid ordinary citizens around the globe are convinced that it is.

From the institutional perspective of nuclear nations, obviously the system of nuclear deterrence is not seen as stupid, because each nuclear power is certain it would be subject to blackmail if it showed weakness by any unilateral disarmament initiative. Without the U.S. nuclear deterrent, perhaps the Chinese would more likely risk invading and subsuming Taiwan, or Putin would be even less restrained in his push for empire than at present. These suppositions do not even include the self-perpetuating momentum provided by the profit motive of the arms manufacturers.

The nuclear nations are stuck in a system which has no exit, no good outcome—unless they realize their common interest in change. As of today 86 countries have signed, and 66 nations have comes to their senses and ratified, the United Nations Treaty on the Prohibition of Nuclear Weapons, good news for all of us.

What will drive the nine nuclear nations toward the realization that they and their citizens share together a probability of annihilation unless they move together toward reciprocal, verifiable arms control? But someone must make the first move that initiates a possible virtuous circle. Why not the U.S.? As former Secretary of Defense Perry suggests, we could retire our entire land-based fleet of ballistic missiles without any loss of security.

The Chinese are said to be unwilling to engage in disarmament talks at the moment. But things can change as the self-interest of nations changes. And every day that the nine cling to their bombs, some other nations feel compelled to seek them.

Strategists know that the arms race and the unfolding of current events in general is an ever-surprising unstable state. But it is clearly difficult for them to look down the time-stream and see that unless we change the nuclear paradigm by aggressively building agreement around the futility of the game, there is a waterfall ahead toward which the world is drifting. Nuclear arms control will inevitably take place in a context of conflicts large and small, including apparent Chinese intransigence and continuing war in Ukraine. But once strategists disenthrall themselves of the supposed necessities of deterrence, a new picture of a shared self-interest in moving beyond the nuclear age may come into focus.

Winslow Myers, author of “Living Beyond War: A Citizen’s Guide,” serves on the Advisory Board of the War Preventive Initiative.

More Resources


03/29/2024
Behind Scenes Stories of Censorship


more info


03/29/2024
Where RFK Jr. Goes From Here


more info


03/29/2024
Will the RFK Factor Make a Difference in 2024?
Robert Kennedy Jr. leads the highest-polling independent presidential ticket in over 30 years

more info


03/29/2024
Democrats May Keep the Senate--With a Little GOP Help
The inexplicable determination of the party's voters to pick unstable provocateurs might be the only path Democrats have to hanging onto their narrow and very much endangered Senate majority.

more info


03/29/2024
You Count Votes Over and Over Until They Add Up Right
By John Kass March 27, 2024 Illinois Gov. J.B. Pritzker-the perpetually frightened rich kid born on third base thinking he hit a triple-has a big fat political problem. He's hosting the Democratic National Convention, his big fat coming out party in Chicago, in August. His fantasy? Becoming president of the United States of America. As he's planning his party, America ... Read More

more info


03/29/2024
The Long Road Back for the Port of Baltimore
For the moment, Maryland officials are focused on crisis management.

more info


03/29/2024
Enough Already
City leaders keep searching for the root cause of crime-they should look in the mirror.

more info


03/28/2024
The Democrats' Abundance Problem Revisited
Last week, I started revisiting my "Three Point Plan to Fix the Democrats and Their Coalition" from October of 2022. A brisk tour of the polling and political data suggested the Democrats are still in need of serious reform and that the three point plan is as relevant as ever. Here's the very short version of the plan:

more info


03/28/2024
Are Democrats Still Stuck With Biden?
Voters don't think much of the president but also remain wary of the obvious replacement.

more info


03/28/2024
What the Polls Say: RFK Jr. Hurting Biden, Helping Trump
In October, when Robert F. Kennedy Jr. abandoned his primary challenge to Joe Biden and instead launched an independent candidacy, the initial conventional wisdom was that he might hurt Donald Trump more than Biden.

more info


03/28/2024
The Twilight of the Republican 'McLeadership'
The Trump team is steadily purging the Republican leadership of holdovers from past decades. The departure of McCarthy, McDaniel, and McConnell is part of exorcising the legacy of a more important Mc whose influence is still felt in the U.S. Senate: John McCain.

more info


03/28/2024
The Funniest Media Story of the Year?
The following three things were obvious before MSNBC puked on itself in its public divorce with former RNC chief Ronna McDaniel, but aren't we glad the network didn't notice? More later, but briefly:

more info


03/28/2024
Abridging, Not Coercing, Is First Amendment's Yardstick
Under the First Amendment, the government may not abridge the freedom of speech, whether that abridging is done by coercing internet platforms or by getting them to cooperate in government efforts to censor the public.

more info


03/28/2024
Trade Cheaters Are Killing Aluminum Industry Jobs
Aluminum industry workers stand ready to do their part to move the nation forward. They just need the federal government to enforce trade laws.

more info


03/28/2024
It's Time for an Immigration Moratorium
An effective freeze on immigration could revitalize our national culture, politics, and economy before it's too late.

more info



Custom Search

More Politics Articles:

Related Articles

America's Nightmare - Congress
I dreamed I had come up with a solution to America's greatest problem, eliminate Congress. Unfortunately when I awakened I was in greater distress because the television was on and Congress was in session haggling. Tragically my dream awakened to America's ongoing nightmare.
Fuel the American Economy with Offshore Energy
Some parting gift: On his way out the White House door, President Barack Obama banned seismic surveying in the Atlantic Ocean from New England south to Virginia.
Encumbrances - State Churches, O'Reilly and Kim Jong Un
An encumbrance will often weigh us down or prevent us from going forward.
Top Border Cop: The Sanders Drug-Importation Bill Keeps Me Awake At Night
A 24-year-old woman recently crossed the Mexican border in Nogales, Arizona on foot, pushing an inconspicuous stroller. In addition to her two young children, it carried five pounds of fentanyl, a deadly opioid 50 times more powerful than heroin. Law enforcement intercepted the drug shipment this time. But many other packages get through, with fatal consequences.
Innovative thinking is the key to resolving the Obamacare replacement dilemma
Support may be growing for the notion that the expansion of Health Savings Accounts can provide a "creative solution" to the Congressional dilemma on how to repeal and replace Obamacare, according to Dan Weber, president of the Association of Mature American Citizens.
Patients Will Die if Congress Doesn't Reauthorize this 25-Year Old Law
Thousands of Americans could die waiting for the FDA to approve new, lifesaving treatments if Congress fails to reauthorize a 25-year old law this summer.
Americans' Issue with Entering and Exiting
We will never figure out health care, Medicaid and most of our country's issues until we learn how to enter and exit buildings.
Rising Chronic Disease Rates Portend Unsustainable Costs
12 percent of Americans suffer from five or more chronic conditions, such as high blood pressure, heart disease, and diabetes. This fraction of the population accounts for 41 percent of total health care spending.
U.S. Senate Misstep Will Cost Jobs and Slow Energy Production
The Senate just failed to roll back an Obama-era regulation that will discourage energy production, cost millions of dollars, and kill thousands of American jobs.
How U.S. natural gas will help countries meet their Paris commitments
While critics bemoan President Trump's decision to pull out of -- or renegotiate -- the Paris climate agreement, the United States has been reducing its greenhouse gas emissions over the past decade. And now the country is poised to help a number of the signatory countries reduce theirs as well.
A 'Made in America' Product Even Free Traders Can Support
President Trump recently announced "Made in America Week," when he emphasized the economic benefits of revitalizing the U.S. manufacturing sector. Many economists push back against such efforts, asserting there are numerous benefits to global trade and economic integration. But there is at least one sector where "Made in America" means a stronger economy, not a weaker one.
America's Government Pension Pain
Stories of struggling government pension funding have abounded the last few months. Reports of changing the retirement scenario for state employees are dominating the conversation in states like New Jersey, Illinois, California and Kentucky.
A Money-Back Guarantee for Prescription Drugs
President Trump will soon issue an executive order to lower drug prices. The order likely will encourage federal health agencies to make greater use of "outcomes-based" contracts.
Prevention Requires a Lot of Effort
Most of us believe in prevention but we don't always practice it. An ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure we've heard before.
Confusion Shouldn't Stop Patients from Buying Health Insurance
This year's Affordable Care Act open enrollment period starts November 1. Millions of Americans will soon visit HealthCare.gov or the online insurance exchange run by their state to shop for 2018 health plans. Many will be confused by what they find.
Energy Companies Have Helped Texas, and the Nation, Recover from Harvey
Hurricane Harvey dumped enough rain on Texas to fill the entire Chesapeake Bay. Widespread flooding caused an estimated $190 billion in damage, meaning Harvey could be the most expensive storm in American history.
Just What the Doctor Ordered
While the Republican Congress remains paralyzed over how to repeal and replace Obamacare, recent activity among two of the healthcare industry's largest players could signal a new approach to delivering access to affordable healthcare. CVS, the nation's largest pharmacy chain, recently announced that it is acquiring Aetna, one of the nation's largest insurers, for a reported $69 billion.
A Merit-based Immigration System Would Help Americans -- and Skilled Foreigners
Don't expect a bigger paycheck anytime soon. Fed Chair Janet Yellen recently admitted there might be far more "slack" in the labor market than she and her colleagues realized, meaning that employers can attract all the workers they need without raising wages.
Proposed Legislation will Fuel the Opioid Epidemic in the U.S.
Consumers better think twice before clicking "purchase" on an internet pharmacy's site.
The Big Button
In 1964, when I was a college freshman, all healthy male students without prior military service were required to take two years of a basic Air Force Reserve Officer Training Course (AFROTC). The Stanley Kubrick movie. Dr. Strangelove: Or How I Learned to Stop Worrying and Love the Bomb, was new. This child of the 1960s now in his 70s has two satirical movies committed to memory: Dr. Strangelove and Animal House.