On John Mearsheimer: Or, is the West really responsible for the Ukrainian crisis?


By Dr. R.B.A. Di Muccio


John Mearsheimer has unquestionably earned our attention on contemporary international relations and on the Ukrainian crisis. Mearsheimer is an academic who specializes in theories of international relations (IR). If you were an IR graduate student in the 1980s or 1990s (I was), you would be very familiar with Mearsheimer and would appreciate his role in fleshing out the “neorealist” version of the realist school of thought. He is a towering figure in the study of international affairs and one of the world’s most prominent IR theorists.

He has also been a rather provocative commentator on foreign affairs. Mearsheimer first became a subject of notoriety when he explained why we would “miss the Cold War.” When that piece was written, there was plenty of guffawing. The West had just declared victory in the Cold War, and here was an obscure academic essentially tossing a wet blanket on the celebration. Nevertheless, the thesis and many of the predictions in the piece wound up being spot on. Moreover, Mearsheimer became famous (or infamous) for arguing in the 1990s that the Ukraine should be permitted to keep its nuclear weapons in a post-Soviet, post-Cold War world as a check on a resurgent Russia that might someday become aggressive. Ukraine might badly need those nukes as a deterrent.

Today, Mearsheimer’s analysis of the Ukrainian crisis has garnered a fresh helping of notoriety. For example, a June lecture version of the article is nearing two million views on YouTube. What’s the big deal?

You need look no further than the title of the article: “John Mearsheimer on Why the West is Principally Responsible for the Ukrainian crisis.”

There it is. A thumb in the eye of Western foreign policy establishment elites spanning eras, countries, and parties. The definition of controversial.

Now, the title is certainly part click bait, and Mearsheimer dutifully qualifies his thesis. But the core argument is unmistakable: the West, and the United States in particular, provoked and therefore caused Russian aggression in Ukraine. This, itself, helps explain much of the controversy. But we should also examine Mearsheimer’s assessment because of the questions it raises about the value of realist theories in understanding contemporary world affairs.

Here’s a basic outline of the argument:

First, through spring 2008, Vladimir Putin had consistently and repeatedly signaled a willingness to allow Ukraine to be independent as long as it remained neutral vis-à-vis the West. Second, implied throughout Mearsheimer’s argument is a completely non-controversial realist assumption: it was and is clearly in Russia’s national security interest to demand and expect Ukrainian neutrality. Therefore, any actions obviously aimed at bringing Ukraine closer to the West or, worse, into NATO, would necessarily be viewed by Russia as an existential threat.

This is exactly what happened, starting in earnest with the April 2008 NATO summit in Bucharest, continuing with many subsequent moves to bring Ukraine closer to the EU and make Ukraine a pro-American democracy. This was followed more recently by a series of steps that made Ukraine a near de facto member of NATO, including U.S. and NATO supplied weapons, the training of Ukrainian forces, multiple joint military exercises and more.

Realism holds that states are perpetually fearful for their security and therefore tend toward competition and conflict. States, being rational actors, have no choice but to act to ensure their survival.

According to Mearsheimer, such calculations fully explain why Russia took Crimea in 2014 and then launched a much broader invasion of Ukraine in February 2022. The West, led by successive U.S. administrations, “recklessly” sought EU and NATO expansion, and thereby needlessly provoked the Ukrainian crisis.

The thesis, though elegant, is not without problems and troubling implications. Mearsheimer offers this qualification: “Putin started the war and is responsible for how it is being waged. But why he did so is another matter.” In other words, the West’s narrative that Putin is just an out-of-touch madman is false. Instead, Putin’s overarching motivations are perfectly rational, even though his methods may not be. But how can the essential motivation be rational but not its outward manifestations? Is Putin a rational actor or not? At what point do presumably non-rational methods undermine, contradict, or call into question the rational ends?

Secondly, Mearsheimer’s thesis leaves the impression that realist expectations of rational, security-seeking action apply to Russia, but not to the West. But what definition of the security motive disqualifies the West’s goals of ensuring that Ukraine is not brought back into a Soviet-style orbit? If the West’s actions over two decades haven’t been the result of rational security calculations, what explanations are left? Miscalculation? Corruption? Evil?

Mearsheimer is obviously outraged that the Western powers challenged Putin in the ways that they did. But his attempt to use realist IR theory to give Putin mostly a pass on the causes of the Ukrainian crisis doesn’t quite stand up to scrutiny.

Is the West principally responsible for the Ukrainian crisis? Western provocation arguably did help occasion the Ukrainian crisis. But if these provocations were simply in pursuit of rational, realist aims, it’s the very structure of contemporary international relations that is the underlying cause of the crisis, not one side or the other.

Yes, this is a gloomy conclusion. But it’s one that arguably follows more faithfully from the realist paradigm than Mearsheimer’s assessment.

Dr. R.B.A. Di Muccio is a guest commentator for the Institute for Faith and Freedom at Grove City College. A former assistant professor and chair of the international relations program in the Political Science Department at the University of Florida, he is now vice president of research and advisory services for a global business advisory firm. He received his Ph.D. in international relations from the University of Southern California.



More Resources


03/27/2024
Biden, Trump Know RFK Jr.'s VP Choice a Game Changer


more info


03/27/2024
Republican 'War on Women' Is a Media Myth
There's no evidence Republicans want to ban birth control. On the contrary, the GOP has led on efforts to make it easier to get birth control over the counter.

more info


03/27/2024
Supreme Court Scoffs at Flimsy Abortion Pill Argument


more info


03/27/2024
NBC's Failed Attempt To Appeal to MAGA Voters
I spent years in the MAGA cult: We loathed Ronna Romney McDaniel almost as much as we loathed the media

more info


03/27/2024
Democrats Are Better for the US Economy
Jeffrey Frankel notes that this is no mere correlation, though the cause remains an enduring puzzle.

more info


03/27/2024
TikTok's Dangerous Influence Over Kids
Congressional talk about TikTok needs to be a wake-up call to parents. The Chinese app exposes kids to dangerous content, especially about suicide. It's 'every parents's nightmare.'

more info


03/27/2024
Smartphones Rewired Childhood. Here's How to Fix It.
Phones have made kids sedentary, solitary, anxious, and depressed. But, says the author and psychologist, we can reverse the damage.

more info


03/27/2024
NBC Cements Status as Anti-Trump, Pro-Biden Network
The dramatic saga following NBC's announced hire of former RNC chair Ronna McDaniel solidified the network's position as being fully anti-Trump going into the 2024 election.

more info


03/27/2024
Don't Tell This 'Double-Hater' She's Crazy
Most of those known as 'double haters' will come around to support one of the two major party presidential nominees. But some, like Victoria Thompson, won't back Trump or Biden under any circumstances.

more info


03/27/2024
Joe Biden, the (Still) Unpopular President
There's been a lot of wishful reporting about the political fortunes and reelection hopes of President Joe Biden.

more info


03/27/2024
Trump's Crumbling Empire Gives Biden a Golden Opportunity
Here's a phrase I never thought I'd say: Donald Trump, Bible salesman.

more info


03/27/2024
Democrats Distort the Law To Subvert 2024 Election
An appeals court just gutted New York's $454 million fine against Trump in ‘a fraud case in which there are no fraud victims.'

more info


03/27/2024
RFK Jr. Makes New Play for Disaffected w/Nicole Shanahan
Mr. Kennedy's allies hope his choice of a wealthy Silicon Valley lawyer to be his running mate will inject new energy and financial support into his independent bid for the White House.

more info


03/27/2024
SCOTUS Must Rely on 1st Amendment Censorship Case
The justices of the Supreme Court never focused on the First Amendment's words when hearing arguments in Murthy v. Missouri last week. The case challenges the federal government's orchestration of social media censorship, so one might have expected the justices to pay some attention to the First Amendment itself.

more info


03/27/2024
The Republican House Fails the Ronald Reagan Test
Following its Friday failure to deliver a new package of aid for Ukraine, it's time for a title change in the US House of Representatives.

more info



Custom Search

More Politics Articles:

Related Articles

The Flu Bug - Don't Touch Porn Stars, Celebrities or Politicians


Where have people's hands been? When you shake hands with someone at church, the grocery store or a restaurant what kind of germs are they carrying?

Senate's Part D Budget Deal Is No Victory for Seniors


Earlier this month, the Senate announced its two-year budget deal. It contains a healthcare provision that many are touting as a victory for American seniors. The reform aims to close the so-called "donut hole" coverage gap in the Medicare Part D drug benefit by shifting more of the program's costs to drug companies.

Alaskan Energy Development: Pro Consumer, Pro Taxpayer, Pro Prosperity


President Trump's tax reform included a bonus for consumers, taxpayers, and Alaska: opening the Arctic National Wildlife Refuge (ANWR) to energy development. Such action reverses a four-decade, Carter-to-Obama animus against developing what the federal government has estimated could be one of the largest oil fields in U.S. history.

Alaskan Energy Development: Pro Consumer, Pro Taxpayer, Pro Prosperity


President Trump's tax reform included a bonus for consumers, taxpayers, and Alaska: opening the Arctic National Wildlife Refuge (ANWR) to energy development. Such action reverses a four-decade, Carter-to-Obama animus against developing what the federal government has estimated could be one of the largest oil fields in U.S. history.

FERC Just Saved Thousands of American Lives


This past January, the independent Federal Energy Regulatory Commission shot down a sweeping proposal from Energy Secretary Rick Perry. By rejecting the proposal, which would have led to dangerous levels of air pollution, FERC helped secure the health of thousands of Americans.

Time to Rethink the Renewable Fuel Standard


Environmental Protection Agency Administrator Scott Pruitt thinks U.S. refiners are forced to blend too much ethanol into their gasoline.

To Cut Drug Prices, Start with the Facts


Americans are paying too much for prescription medicines. State lawmakers are fed up with Washington's apathy towards high pharmacy bills. So they're taking matters into their own hands and pushing forward with several bills.

The Grove City Bill: A President vs. Congress


We wrote earlier about the Grove City College Supreme Court case (Grove City College v. Bell) in which the high court ruled that any "financial assistance" used by students and their families to pay for their education at Grove City College made the college a "recipient." What did this mean and what were the implications?

Russian Trolls are Pitting Americans Against Energy Industry


According to a March report from the House Science, Space and Technology Committee, Russian trolls are trying to disrupt U.S. energy markets.

The Revised NAFTA Must Protect New Drugs


President Trump hopes to finalize changes to the North American Free Trade Agreement by early May. For months, he has urged his trade negotiators to rework the pact in a way that reduces America's trade deficit.

Don't Just Do Infrastructure. America Needs Comprehensive Economic Development.


President Trump recently proposed a $1.5 trillion infrastructure program. It's generally a good idea. But infrastructure alone will not produce long-term inclusive growth. To achieve that, America instead needs a comprehensive economic development strategy.

Russain Trolls are Pitting Americans Against Energy Industry


According to a March report from the House Science, Space and Technology Committee, Russian trolls are trying to disrupt U.S. energy markets.

The Life (and Death) of American Farmers


Recent reports from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention indicate that suicide rates among American farmers are higher than any other occupational group, and five times higher than that of the population as a whole. One is tempted to argue that this reflects the decline of community life in rural America.

Trump's Trade War Is Economic Suicide


When President Trump imposed a 25 percent tariff on steel imports America's largest nail manufacturer had little choice but to raise prices. Mid Continent Nail Corporation lost 50 percent of its orders as customers opted for cheaper suppliers. Within weeks, the firm laid off 60 workers. And 200 more might lose their jobs by the end of July.

John McCain - Chart a New Course


I respected Senator John McCain. I loved him as a war hero and a fellow American who served his country in an astounding way. Few people in our country will ever accomplish all that McCain accomplished in his life. He served his country in the military, suffered as a prisoner of war and became one of the most respected United States Senators in our nation's history.

Labor Day - Deal With The Stuff


Labor Day Weekend gives Americans across the country a three-day weekend to rest, travel and celebrate our freedom to labor. Our jobs increased by two million people in 2017 and have continued to climb in 2018. Hourly wages have seen gains and the stock market has seen twenty months of phenomenal growth. Employers across the country need workers and job seekers have options.

Audio Recordings - Omarosa, President Trump and Billy Graham


Perfect people will never work in government. People make promises and look good in television advertisements but people are people and that always means human error.

Grease FDA Wheels to Save Lives


When you're desperately ill, your chances of recovery improve as your access to treatment improves. That's why it's such good news that the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) is working to speed up the process of getting new medications to patients.

Hope Springs Eternal: Forty Years of Egyptian-Israeli Peace


March 26, 2019 marks the 40th anniversary of the Egyptian-Israeli Peace Treaty. Historians consider the Egyptian-Israeli peace brokered by President Jimmy Carter in the late 1970s to be the most important and impressive diplomatic achievement of an administration otherwise plagued by foreign crises.

Materialism Has Become Both a New Religion And A New Political Cause


The 21st Century has brought us a boatload of new technology, an abundance of leisure time and a newfound focus on materialistic ethics. It's a new world in which we live but it is the kind of world in which pessimism, disrespect and wrong-minded beliefs and objectives beset the younger generations.