Time to Expose America's Secret Lawsuit Gambling Ring


By Bob Goodlatte and Lamar Smith


Hedge funds have found a new way to juice their returns: betting on lawsuits.

This practice is called third party litigation funding (TPLF) and is a massive threat to our most important institutions. According to a recent study by the nonpartisan Government Accountability Office (GAO), TPLF has exploded in the last few years. Under these arrangements, a financial backer -- such as a hedge fund -- will secretly finance and may even control a lawsuit in return for a share of any eventual settlement or award. Often, the defendant, the judge and sometimes even the plaintiffs don't know if a lawsuit has outside funding.

By treating America's legal system as just another financial transaction on which to gamble, third party litigation funding is making it harder for defendants to resolve cases and harder for plaintiffs to get justice.

Funding arrangements often end up causing more harm than good in any number of ways. For example, according to the GAO, TPLF carries a risk "that a funder paying for the litigation may exert control over the case (such as influencing decisions about litigation strategy or whether to settle)."

The risk is hardly theoretical. Funders have openly admitted their effect on litigation for years: the chief investment officer at the U.S. division of IMF Bentham Ltd., another major litigation finance firm, told The Wall Street Journal that "We make it harder and more expensive to settle cases."

Litigation financing firms have every reason to drag out litigation in the hope of "hitting the jackpot" at trial. After all, litigation finance firms often demand a high return from plaintiffs on the upfront legal fees that the financiers fronted -- which means they may pressure (or prevent) a plaintiff from accepting an otherwise reasonable settlement offer.

The GAO also recognized that sovereign wealth funds could use TPLF to "influence litigation" in order "to further foreign policy or military goals." Indeed, since funding agreements aren't disclosed, there's little to stop an unfriendly foreign government from employing third-party litigation funding to covertly influence our legal system in ways that compromise America's interests. This form of foreign interference could be carried out on a massive scale without ever breaking a U.S. law.

Despite the significant dangers this practice entails, third party litigation funding remains mostly unregulated. Last year, by some estimates, litigation funders invested a whopping $3.2 billion in lawsuits throughout the country -- a 16% increase from the previous year.

That figure is almost certain to keep rising in the years ahead -- unless, of course, lawmakers and regulators take action.

Fortunately, members of both political parties, and both Houses of Congress, are beginning to take action. The House Oversight Committee, under the leadership of Chairman James Comer (R-KY), held a hearing to examine the numerous problems posed by unrestricted and unregulated TPLF. Shortly after, Sens. John Kennedy (R-LA) and Joe Manchin (D-W.Va.) introduced the "Protecting Our Courts from Foreign Manipulation Act of 2023" to ensure that foreign sovereign wealth funds cannot weaponize our judicial system to the disadvantage of America's economic and national security.

As former chairmen of the House Judiciary Committee, we believe that without significant reforms, outside funders will continue to use America's courts as a veritable craps table. We should not let funders enrich themselves, harm plaintiffs, and damage our national interests at the expense of the integrity of our litigation system.

Bob Goodlatte and Lamar Smith are former members of Congress and past chairmen of the House Judiciary Committee.



More Resources


05/05/2024
Biden Has a Problem With Centrist Voters
Biden won the 2020 Democratic nomination as a self-described centrist, but has since adopted more liberal policies that could cost him in 2024.

more info


05/05/2024
Close Presidential Race Careens Toward Uncertain End


more info


05/05/2024
It's the Democrats' Turn To Scare America
No one should be surprised it ended up here.

more info


05/05/2024
Is Trump on Track To Blow the Election?


more info


05/05/2024
The Trump Trial, Columbia Anarchy--and Hope for New York


more info


05/05/2024
New Polls Show Kennedy a Growing Threat to Both Parties
By Adam Garrie, The Kennedy Beacon

more info


05/05/2024
'Equity' Grading Is Latest Educational Fad Destined To Fail
Why work extra hard when you won't be able to get an A? Why try to improve when you won't get worse than a C?

more info


05/05/2024
How Student Encampments Can Strengthen U.S.
Instead of defending the right to protest, many centrists are delegitimizing students, despite the value of what they're doing

more info


05/05/2024
Protesters Should Learn What Genocide Is
Universities are obliged to allow free speech. They are also obliged to make sure that students can attend classes free of harassment.

more info


05/05/2024
From Idealism to Irresponsibility


more info


05/05/2024
Venture Capital's Space for Sheep
vcs should invest in companies that create hype cycles, rather than those that simply follow them

more info


05/05/2024
Trump's Terrible, Horrible, No Good, Very Bad 2nd Term
Millions of us are justifiably focused on seeing that Donald Trump is held to account for what he's allegedly done in the past.

more info


05/05/2024
Biden Can't Win in a Fair Election Against Trump
Former President Donald Trump is getting dragged through the courts via the "lawfare" charges manufactured against him - and seemingly millions of liberals and Democrats are ecstatic. Chaos, turmoil and pain such as this can feel exhilarating when it's the other side's ox being gored.

more info


05/05/2024
Kennedy Jr.'s Plan To Make Biden Drop Out
Independent presidential candidate Robert F. Kennedy Jr. says President Joe Biden is the real "spoiler" in the 2024 presidential race, and he has a plan to make Biden drop out.

more info


05/05/2024
The Adults Are Still in Charge at the University of Florida
Higher education isn't daycare. Here are the rules we follow on free speech and public protests.

more info



Custom Search

More Politics Articles:

Related Articles

Trump's Socialist Attack on Americans' Health and Medical INnovations Must Be Stopped


Imagine if Barack Obama signed an executive order implementing socialist price controls on prescription drugs. And suppose that decision limited the drugs available to patients, dried up funding for innovative new treatments and resulted in the unnecessary deaths of thousands of Americans a year.

Biden Won't Win Votes by Threatening Swing State Jobs


It sometimes seems as if former Vice President Biden is hell bent on losing this November.

New Drug Pricing Executive Order Burdens Patients


President Trump just signed an executive order designed to reduce drug prices. Dubbed a "Most Favored Nations" policy, the order pegs Medicare payments for medicines to the prices paid by foreign governments.

Enjoy Your Usual Life, But Vote


Occasionally we all feel like we are living in a rut. Our days and weeks are filled with the same activities and schedules. We mow grass, rake leaves, clean the house, sweep out the garage and do the same jobs. We go to the same grocery store on a certain day, wash our car at the same place and see the same people along the way. We go to the same place of worship, and read the same daily or weekly newspaper. Our lives are made up of routines, schedules and the usual.

The Sun is Shining


The Sun is shining today and will rise tomorrow. For more years than we know the Sun has followed this same pattern.

Giving Thanks to Society’s Economic Benefactors


With all the attention commanded by the presidential campaign, election, and aftermath, plus the ongoing COVID-19 story, many other issues have faded into the background. Though escaping the headlines, some of these other issues will be with us for a long time, and contributions to the public discussion of such issues will often have a long-term impact.

Importing Drugs Endangers Lives


On most issues, Democrats and Republicans remain deeply divided. But there's one policy that unites both -- prescription drug importation.

On the Impeachment and Conviction of President Trump


The House of Representatives, with the sole responsibility of impeachment, has passed a single Article of Impeachment charging President Donald Trump with committing a high crime, namely that he “made statements that encouraged—and foreseeably resulted in—imminent lawless action at the Capitol.” In short, his rally speech, it is claimed, amounted to “incitement to engage in the insurrection.”

Death of a Defector: Ion Mihai Pacepa, RIP


On February 14, 2021, the world quietly lost one of the most intriguing, enduring figures of the Cold War. He was Lt. Gen. Ion Mihai Pacepa, the highest-ranking Soviet Bloc official ever to defect to the United States.

Stop Businesses From Exploiting This Health Program for the Poor


Over the decades, Congress has created a number of programs intended to help the poor, the sick, the downtrodden. As a result, certain businesses and industries find ways to exploit these efforts and profit in ways lawmakers never foresaw or intended.

Preventing the Next Public Health Crisis Can Define Biden's Legacy


The Biden administration's plan to defeat the coronavirus is underway -- and notably includes intentions to "build better preparedness for future threats." This detailed guidance could not have come at a better time. While we are making progress against the current pandemic, we remain in the midst of a worsening health crisis posed by antibiotic resistance.

For Seniors' Sake, Protect the Innovation that Brought Us Covid Vaccines


The breakneck pace of Covid-19 vaccine development will go down in history books as one of the great triumphs of modern medicine.

Raise the Corporate Tax Rate? Economic Obtuseness in High Places


Having proposed trillions of dollars of additional federal spending, President Joe Biden and allies have launched a belated and somewhat desperate search for additional tax revenues. The economic reality is that there simply isn’t enough wealth available in the private sector to fund the explosion in government spending. The danger is that changes in the tax code may do more damage than good.

America's Goose that Lays the Golden Eggs


America's research and development institutions have long been the envy of our competitors, flourishing at the top of global rankings. But our state-of-the-art innovation capabilities — responsible for bringing COVID-19 vaccines and countless other breakthroughs to market — haven't flourished here by happenstance. They have been nurtured over decades of smart policies, and those policies are now at risk.

A Public Option Will Destroy Private Insurance


Congress is trying to chart a path forward on health reform. Several congressional Democrats just announced plans to draft a bill that would create a public health insurance option.