Sexuality Information

Homosexuality: Lets Reopen the Debate!


I wonder why, in the current cultural war over "gays" in general and whether they should marry in particular, no one speaks publicly of the issue of choice? Is it a closed issue?

I mean, isn't the whole gay premise that since being gay is an innate, genetic trait, and since they cannot help being gay, that they should, as any other ethnic group, marry and even raise children? And how many times have we read that homosexuality is like race? It is like someone being black. That's a horrible analogy but it is what the gays say.

So, let me see if I am getting this. If being gay is like being black, and being gay works itself out in one's behavior as having sex with someone of the same sex, then how does being black work itself out in the behavior of a black person? Or, to carry this absurdity even further, how about a Chinese person? How does being Chinese work itself out in the behavior of a Chinese person? How does a Chinese person behave? What if the Chinese person is a Chinese-American, born and bred in the U.S.A.? How then would that work? Is it not someone's behavior and not a state of being that we are talking about?

What I sincerely don't get is just who says that someone that has sex with a member of the same sex does so as the result of being in the condition of being gay? To put it into the words of the "politically correct" engineered vocabulary, "Just who says that same sex behavior is the result of a same sex orientation?" Who came up with this notion?

Let's try, even though we are laymen, to be scientific about this. I mean, after all cannot laymen understand complex issues?

Was this sexual orientation business derived from employing the scientific method? Was 1) observation, 2) hypothesis, 3) prediction, 4) testing, and the attempt to 5) replicate steps 3 and 4 used to form a theory (the last step of the scientific method) that homosexual orientation is innate and therefore cannot change?

Here is an example of the breakdown of what this should have looked like to come up with a cogent theory:

Observation: Some men and women have sexual relations with members of the same sex. Is there a genetic drive that causes some individuals to want to have same-sex relations?

Hypothesis: A possible explanation for this observation is that some individuals are genetically inclined or oriented to having same-sex relations. And by the way, there can be multiple hypotheses to test the question formed out of the observation.

In other words, there could be many possible hypotheses (educated guesses) to explain the observation. But, all you hear in the media is the one premise--innate and unchangeable.

Predictions: If it is genetic, then in identical twins (being genetic clones) where one member of the pair is a homosexual, the other member will be homosexual too. There will have to be a 100% certainty that both twins will be gay.

Testing: Then the scientists come up with a way to test the predicted results via experimentation.

Replication: Other scientists try to replicate the initial experiment to see if they come up with the same or nearly the same results.

Theory: When the same consistent results are reached through many studies, then a theory is formed. A theory is a well-tested hypothesis.

That is a simple, layman's explanation of the scientific method. Where I am having the most trouble, about the entire homosexual issue, is at the testing stage (step 4) in the scientific method mentioned above. Do you test this hypothesis in a lab? No. You do a series of survey-like studies. For the sake of brevity, let me share with you one study done to attempt to verify this hypothesis.

In the study, A Genetic Study of Male Sexual Orientation, researchers Michael Bailey and Richard C. Pillard discovered in their sample group that half of the identical twins pairs were both gay while the other half had one gay member in the pair and the other was heterosexual. That means a 50% concordance rate. A concordant twin-pair would mean that both twins' members were gay while a disconcordant twin-pair would have one gay member and one straight member.

The immediate and glaring problem here is that identical twins are genetic clones of each other. If one member of the twin pair is gay, and being gay is a genetically coded thing, then the other member of the twin pair must be gay also. It would be impossible to have anything other than a 100% concordance rate.

If being gay is genetically caused, then in identical twin-pairs, both members would be DNA coded for homosexuality.

The testability of Bailey and Pillard's hypothesis troubles me for 5 reasons:

1) To be accurate, one would have to survey identical twins raised in different environments and not in the same environment. Raised in the same environment would seriously taint the proposition that genetics and not environmental issues were the determining factor in a homosexual orientation with concordant twin-pairs. In other words, how could you be 100% sure the determining factor in the orientation development of the concordant twin-pair wasn't influenced by their environment?

2) The way in which Bailey and Pillard obtained their research subjects was by advertising in homosexual publications. Concordant identical twin-pairs responded more often to the ads than disconcordant twin-pairs where one member was gay and then other one was not. Was this a true representation of the homosexual community?

Too, how accurate is self-reporting? In these studies, the researchers asked a homosexual how he/she knows he/she is gay, the usual responses are, "I have always felt different.", or "The earliest memories I have is feeling different from members of my sex."--how is that objective? Wouldn't a gay person, who is interested in absolving himself of the guilt of his sexual behavior or interested in promoting the gay socio-political position, have everything to gain in spouting the "party line"--I was born that way? Worse yet, what if he so believes the party line that he is self-deluded? Likely?

Scarier things have happened.

To offer human experience as the basis for establishing truth is a risky business indeed. Anyone can have an experience and claim it is true. There can be as many experiences as there are people to have them! If a billion people of the planet's population came forward and claimed that they have always felt like a dog, would that make it true? If they claimed that their earliest memories were that of feeling "different" from humans, would that validate their claim as true? What if they even said that they've done dog-like things all their childhood and, even as adults, eating Alpo and barking when someone comes to the door? Would that make it true?

Self-reporting from a biased population is not an accurate way of obtaining objective results.

3) Often, only one of the twin-pair members participated in the study and reported on the sexual orientation of the twin-pair member who didn't participate in the study. Again, this taints the study and does not insure accurate results.

4) The 50% concordant rate that did surface in the study could have been affected by the extreme genetic similarity of identical twins can exaggerate concordance rates. This taints statistical results.

5) The authors of the study believed that in concordant twin-pairs, those in which both were homosexual, that both would report the subjective claim that their earliest possible memories were of that being different from other boys. They reasoned this because if being gay was genetic, then this subjective claim of "childhood gender non-conformity" (Jeffrey Satinover, M.D.; Homosexuality and the Politics of Truth; page 86) would have been present at the earliest possible memories in both twin-pairs. It was not the case.

"But just as the twin studies failed to demonstrate genetic causation, their twin pairs in which both were homosexual experienced "childhood gender nonconformity" no more frequently than did the single homosexual in a discordant pair. Although an early recollection of "being different" is thus common among homosexuals, the evidence suggests that this sense of difference is in fact not caused by something genetic." (Jeffrey Satinover, M.D.; Homosexuality and the Politics of Truth; page 87).

It is this study, with two other major ones, on which the media bases their "proof positive" claim that homosexuality is genetically based. These three studies have been the battle cry for the gay movement. Yet, the other two studies, as with the Bailey and Pillard study, did not come up with the results hoped for by their authors. The result: homosexuality is not genetic. What does this make of the gay movement's "proof positive" claim of genetic causation?

How can one hope to test the subjective claim of having always "felt different" from the other boys or girls, or as in the Dr. Satinover's term, "childhood gender non-conformity"? Why is only one hypothesis ever considered in the arena of public discussion and debate--that homosexuality is genetic thus innate and unchangeable--when the studies the gays so loudly trumpet as proof are, in reality, no proof at all?

Those who control the flow of information, the press, have the responsibility to tell both sides of the issue. It is irresponsible not to and it is neither fair nor balanced.

Think about this: The desire to eat food is a genuine biological drive to survive. But what we put into our mouths to eat is our choice. The desire to have sex is a genuine biological drive (but not necessary to survive as an individual), but how and with whom we choose to have sex is a choice! Think about it!

Doug Bower is a freelance writer and book author. His most recent writing credits include The Atlanta Journal-Constitution, The Houston Chronicle, and The Philadelphia Inquirer, and Transitions Abroad. He lives with his wife in Guanajuato, Mexico.

His new book Mexican Living: Blogging it from a Third World Country can be seen at http://www.lulu.com/content/126241


MORE RESOURCES:
Relationships:Sexuality Articles from EzineArticles.com
02/24/2020 09:01 AM
Intercourse Is Totally Defined by Male Responses
Men are aroused in anticipation of sex. Only men can initiate intercourse. The timing of an orgasm is unpredictable.
02/19/2020 09:13 AM
Intercourse Is an Act of Mating & Impregnation
Extended thrusting is typical of mammals. Manual contacts, oral sex & penetrative sex. Some men enjoy the turn-on of foreplay.
02/10/2020 09:16 AM
Platonic Love Is Just As Powerful As Sexual Love
Men initiate relationships for sexual reasons. Women cement relationships by offering sex. Women enjoy sensuality, affection & companionship. l
02/05/2020 08:24 AM
The Romantic Pleasure a Woman Enjoys From Sex
Women are reassured by male arousal & admiration. A woman chooses to be penetrated when she loves a man. Offering sex gives a woman more emotional control.
01/29/2020 09:57 AM
How to Break Free From Sexual Jealousy to Have a Fulfilling, Orgasmic Relationship
By the laws of the land, Shae must have a threesome in order to be with his beloved. It goes against his personal rules as he believes in sexuality without comparison. Comparison leads to jealousy. He fears sexual failure and embarrassment, leading to jealousy. He believes his jealousy creates hate, making it impossible to love the one he desires. Will he become asexual? Will he become hateful? Will he become decadent? Will he find love?
01/28/2020 02:51 PM
Women Do Not Need to Be Like Men to Be Valid
Women making money out by selling bravado. Many women have low expectations for sex. Girls need facts for their own protection.
01/21/2020 10:14 AM
Ego Means Men Overlook What Women Contribute
Men want to maximise their sexual opportunities. Men rarely acknowledge the effort women make. Women tend to avoid conflict.
01/15/2020 09:54 AM
Men's Sex Drive Can Cause Them to Be Insensitive
Male sex drive is irrepressible no matter how women respond. Men become bad-tempered if they don't get regular sex. Consent would not be an issue if intercourse caused female orgasm.
01/06/2020 10:33 AM
Intercourse Is the Heterosexual Lovemaking Act
Women choose men as protectors & providers. Women focus on upper body lovemaking. Women offer sex to get companionship & support.
01/02/2020 11:13 AM
Women Drive the Need for Dating and Romance
For men, sex is intimacy. Men are much more dangerous than women ever are. Women need an emotional attachment to offer sex.
12/23/2019 09:40 AM
Sexual Attraction & Commitment to a Relationship
Sexual attraction & emotional attachments. Marriage protects a woman's interests. Unhealthy relationships & arguing.
12/16/2019 08:37 AM
Understanding the Value of Non-Sexual Intimacy
Men & women experience intimacy in different ways. Women are reluctant to share their bodies. Men are reluctant to share their thoughts.
12/09/2019 11:54 AM
Men Cannot Accept That Women Are Unresponsive
Men's emotional beliefs. Men are impervious to feedback of any kind. Men do not understand women's emotional needs.
12/02/2019 03:12 PM
Why Women Do Not Orgasm From Cunnilingus
Cunnilingus parallels the male role in intercourse. Cunnilingus does not stimulate the internal organ. Cunnilingus is a male erotic turn-on.
11/22/2019 01:13 PM
Why Women Cannot Orgasm Through Intercourse
Women orgasm much less frequently than men do. Women need more time to orgasm than men do. Intercourse does not stimulate the clitoris.
11/18/2019 07:16 PM
How We Know That the Vagina Is Not a Sex Organ
Vagina is part of the birth canal & quite insensitive. The vagina cannot respond erotically being non-erectile. A cavity can always be penetrated.
11/11/2019 10:39 AM
How the Male and Female Sexual Roles Differ
Women only orgasm because they have a phallus. The male arousal cycle. Female orgasm is a miracle of evolution.
11/07/2019 08:07 AM
Why Talking About Sex From the Beginning Is a Must
As a psychotherapist I work with numerous couples that go to the workplace looking for some kind of sexual mending from long stretches of quietness and fermenting contemplations. One of my first inquiries is; what amount is sex a subject of discussion?
11/04/2019 10:03 AM
Why Men Feel Inadequate Over Penis Size
Growers versus showers. Men hope to impress others. An erect penis is a sign of male potency.
10/28/2019 10:04 AM
Why Women Feel Inadequate About Their Bodies
Women are not attracted by genitals & nudity. Women compete with each other for male attention. Men sexualise women's anatomy to assist with arousal.
10/23/2019 09:37 AM
The Internal Anatomy Involved in Reproduction
Wolffian ducts develop into the male reproductive organs. M?llerian ducts grow into the female reproductive organs. There is a single static egg but many tiny mobile sperm.
10/16/2019 09:46 AM
The Female Erectile Sex Organ (or Phallus)
The sex organ develops from the genital tubercle. A sex organ is also internal to the body & is erectile. The corpora caverosa are within the internal clitoral organ.
10/07/2019 04:14 PM
The Male Erectile Sex Organ (or Phallus)
The penis has 3 separate functions. Men are inordinately proud of their penis. The penis has a shaft which contains the corpora cavernosa.
09/30/2019 09:17 AM
Human Sexual Anatomy and Development
The internal reproductive organs. The phallus is an erectile sex organ. Sexual differentiation.
09/23/2019 09:11 AM
Lesbianism Focuses on Longer-Term Relationships
Some lesbians are looking for political recognition. Orientation does not affect responsiveness. Women are often unaware of their orientation.
09/16/2019 09:21 AM
Male Homosexuality Focuses on Casual Sex
Taboo over anal sex. No one can change their sex or orientation. Gay men can be highly promiscuous.
09/09/2019 10:01 AM
Orientation Is Defined by Who We Are Attracted to
Gays are no different to anyone else. Women focus on companionship & affection. Men focus on arousal & penetrative sex.
09/03/2019 08:52 AM
How We Know Someone Has Had an Orgasm
Orgasm is a basic physiological response of the human body. We cannot predict the timing of an orgasm. Orgasm is a repeatable experience.
08/26/2019 01:58 PM
Characteristics of Low Responsiveness
Women enjoy sharing affectionate companionship. Women prefer sex within long-term relationships. Women are not sexually proactive with a lover.
08/19/2019 10:02 AM
Factors That Affect the Strength of Male Sex Drive
Age is the most significant factor. Education seems to affect frequency of masturbation. Uneducated men have the highest overall responsiveness.
08/12/2019 08:58 AM
Characteristics of High Responsiveness
Men enjoy talking about fantasies & erotic turn-ons. Men typically initiate sex with a female lover. Some men are much more faithful than others.
08/05/2019 10:32 AM
Sexual Responsiveness Is a Male Characteristic
Orgasm is primarily a male response that triggers ejaculation. Male sexual ego & giving a woman an orgasm. Female responsiveness is an anomaly of evolution.
07/29/2019 12:23 PM
Responsiveness Varies Between Individuals
Responsiveness occurs randomly in the population. Arousal depends on a positive response to eroticism. We are only motivated by the need we feel.
07/23/2019 05:02 PM
Sexual Responsiveness & Orientation
Responsiveness is innate - we are born that way, Men are much more responsive than women. Orientation is defined by who we are attracted to.
07/16/2019 05:06 PM
Undressing a Woman With Your Eyes
Recently a friend of mine confessed that whenever he saw a woman or met one at a party or a function he always undressed her with his eyes. He fantasized about how she would look without clothes, without her sari and blouse. He further told me that he would also imagine how she would look with her lingerie and sometimes wondered whether she was wearing any at all.
07/15/2019 10:48 AM
Over Time Women Often Become Focused on Family
Women may enjoy providing for the needs of others. Obligations of marriage - regular sex vs. support. Women are told they should enjoy sex.
07/08/2019 09:50 AM
Young Women Tend to Focus on Their Attractiveness
Attracting male attention - women's role in arousing men. Women look for affection from men. Women define their lives in terms of their relationships.
07/02/2019 10:44 AM
At Puberty Girls Develop a Child-Bearing Capacity
Girls are much more timid & passive than boys. Girls focus on relationships rather than eroticism. Ovulation is a subconscious process.
06/24/2019 11:39 AM
Men Tend to Focus on Opportunities for Regular Sex
Male sexual frustration. The dog & ball theory. Men's needs are immediate & obvious.
06/19/2019 10:51 AM
Young Men Tend to Focus on Enjoying Their Arousal
Adolescent boys & men are aroused on a regular basis. Men do not associate sex with emotional attachment. Intercourse frequencies depend on male sex drive.
06/10/2019 09:26 AM
At Puberty Boys Develop a Reliable Arousal Cycle
Boys focus on doing & fighting. Boys are sexually active from adolescence onwards. Orgasm is the trigger for ejaculation.
06/04/2019 10:35 AM
5 Tips to Locate the Best Sexologist
For enjoying a blissful conjugal life, the couple has to have excellent compatibility, love, and respect for each other. Besides, sex also plays a significant role in preserving a man and woman relationship. But in countries like India, talking about sex and sexual problems is still a taboo which so far has been the reason for the destruction of many happy relationships and marriages.
06/03/2019 10:22 AM
The Influence of Religious Beliefs on Sexuality
Culture & family can affect sexuality. Justification of marriage - regular sex versus support for family. Sex is taboo because of differences in responsiveness.
05/27/2019 04:01 PM
Responsibility for Contraception and Abortion
Men do not dwell on consequences in general. Responsibility for contraception & abortion is attributed to women. Personal hygiene, genital infections, AIDs & STDs.
05/21/2019 12:48 PM
Diversity: Our Sex, Our Personality and Our Gender
Our sex is determined before birth & cannot be changed. Only men can obtain sexual gratification from others. Gender is a concept based on society stereotypes.
05/13/2019 10:01 AM
Reproduction Involves More Than Just Intercourse
We have two sexes because they are different to each other. Men's key reproductive focus is intercourse & enjoying arousal. Women's key reproductive focus is enjoying affection & family.
05/09/2019 03:30 PM
How to Choose a Bisexual Dating Site
Are you bisexual? Do you want to find the right dating partner for you? If yes, make a try online. This article will help you righteously. The matter of fact is that the mainstream heterosexual society has started accepting bisexuality as a common form of relationship. In spite of having debates and sharp controversies, it has been considered as an authentic sexual orientation
05/06/2019 09:58 AM
Everyone Achieves Orgasm in Similar Ways
Orgasm is a basic response of the human body. Mental arousal is required before stimulation is effective. Emotional stimuli cannot cause orgasm.
04/29/2019 10:19 AM
Explaining Men & Women's Sexual Behaviours
Men enthusiasm & women's embarrassment over sex. Women's sexual passivity with a lover. Gay men are highly promiscuous.
04/22/2019 10:50 AM
Justifying Biological & Evolutionary Precedents
Other female mammals do not appear to orgasm. Male orgasm is key to reproduction. Female orgasm plays no role in reproduction.


home | site map
© 2006